News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by macspoofing on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:01AM (#23870532)
>But don’t be fooled. The world’s economies are moving away from fossil fuels.

To what?!? If your geography does not allow for large scale hydro or geothermal development, then your only alternative is Nuclear or Fossil Fuels. Solar and wind need base load provided by Fossil Fuels to be remotely viable and clearly are not capable of replacing fossil fuels.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by imtringued on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:09AM (#23871334)
I don't know why you talk about "base load". Base load is incompatible with intermittent energy sources. What you need is something that can be turned on and off to follow the current demand. Natural gas plants are generally used for this role.

I think it is unfortunate that many people are vilifying natural gas. It's almost as if they aren't aware that the main benefit of natural gas plants is that you can turn them off when needed. Grids have to become more flexible if they want a high percentage of renewable energy. It's not like natural gas is cheaper than renewables. The plants will only burn gas when necessary.

What is happening right now is that "Base load" (aka coal plants) is clogging up the electric grid in Germany. On some days you have a really good amount of renewables but the coal keeps running because it can't adjust quickly enough.

When you consider that thanks to the EEG surcharge the operators of renewable power plants still get paid despite producing no power you can see how this lead to the unreasonably high electricity prices in Germany.

This is not a problem with renewables though. The EEG is one of the most poorly though out political instruments to encourage renewables. Basically almost every energy intensive business gets an exemption so all the costs are borne by consumers. A carbon tax would have none of these issues. The coal plants would be shut down because they are bad for business.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by johanvts on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:36AM (#23870934)
In Denmark we have switched largely to solar and wind with backup provided by burning of biomass (largely imported wood pellets from Canada and the USA, but also domestic bio-trash which is sorted separately in many homes).

But even without that, nuclear, wind and solar combined with lots of batteries (stationary and in all the cars) seems like a totally achievable solution. Especially in Europe and America where you have lots of varied geography and can get hydro, solar, thermal and wind to supplement each other, see example the plans for Denmark (wind), Norway (hydro), UK (nuclear).

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by koheripbal on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:48AM (#23871092)
30-40% of Denmark's power is still fossil fuels, and another 10-15% is imports from neighbors when the wind isn't blowing.

source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Denmark#...

Also, RE Bio & waste emit CO2 - they are not particularily clean.

source: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1757-1707....

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by Androider on Friday July 17, 2020 @06:52PM (#23876949)
Even in this already a few year old data you linked, the fossil fuel share has gone from 70%+ to just 30% since 2005. That's nothing short of amazing, and the trend is clear.
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by teraku on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:53AM (#23871165)
Outdated sources are outdated.

https://www.electricitymap.org/zone/DK-DK1

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by koheripbal on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:59AM (#23871237)
How is showing us one day's data evidence of anything?
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by teraku on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:17AM (#23870688)
This is not true. There is a bunch of papers and releases by universities, that show that if you manage your power grid properly, which is already done for any grid having more than 15% renewables, you actually gain an advantage with their flexibility and can work around any base-load problem.
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by macspoofing on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:20AM (#23870718)
>you actually gain an advantage with their flexibility and can work around any base-load problem.

I'm not sure what you mean by 'base-load problem', but what I mean is that you need a fossil-fuel base-load.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by teraku on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:50AM (#23871123)
>you need a fossil-fuel base-load.

Basically saying this is wrong.

Technically, base-load refers to the minimum amount of energy demand on a given day. All sources and studies I have are from Germany, but our parliament, their adjacent (technical) offices and the universities here have concluded that "base-load" as a concept is wrong with today's power generation and the way a power grid works. Today they usually talk about residual-load, turning the paradigm around. Regardless of how it works, there are also renewable energies which can fulfil this classical "base-load" idea: Namely organic gas or geothermal power plants.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by macspoofing on Friday July 17, 2020 @12:03PM (#23871965)
>Regardless of how it works, there are also renewable energies which can fulfil this classical "base-load" idea: Namely organic gas or geothermal power plants.

Why is Germany investing billions in NEW pipeline projects to ship natural gas from Russia for the next few decades? Germany says a lot of nice sweet-nothings, but their actions don't match their words.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by teraku on Saturday July 18, 2020 @06:16AM (#23880362)
Well, first of all the parliament and the government are distinct entities. Government also is very corrupt and slowly changing. An advantage of gas pipelines is they can potentially be repurposed, for example to ship organic gas.

Your statement says nothing about the feasibility, just politics.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by gerbal on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:29AM (#23870828)
Do various sorts of batteries (gravity, fly-wheels, LiON) provide reasonable alternatives for some base load and peak generation?
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by imtringued on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:36AM (#23871665)
I personally am a fan of gravity batteries but the amount of scammy companies operating in the space is dragging the entire field down. The energy density of weights is really low so manufacturing a weight is absolutely uneconomical. What you want to do is take material from a landscape. Usually this means pumping water up a hill but you can also carve out a hydraulic cylinder out of the landscape and use water to lift it. [0] It has absolutely insane scaling potential. Energy capacity grows like so: r^4. Doubling the radius increases energy capacity 16 fold. Energy storage up to 1.6TWh is definitively possible.

Of course this is so ambitious that it might never get built but I can definitively tell you that a crane system like this would be barely economical [1] because weights are really expensive but it's a good attempt and can be refined further.

And finally here is an example of a scam concept: [2]

Digging shafts is unaffordable unless you reuse old mine shafts which would reduce the number of shafts in the picture to just a single one. If you can only have one weight per generator that means the system doesn't scale. The power density of lifting a 1000 ton rock 100m high is pathetic. It's just 270kWh. The cost of the concrete is negligible in this scenario but you won't find a generator that is cheap enough to compete with a conventional battery.

However, to stay realistic. Gravity batteries are about as likely to happen as everyone suddenly switching to nuclear power. The odds aren't great.

[0] http://www.eduard-heindl.de/energy-storage/energy-storage-sy...

[1] https://insights.globalspec.com/images/assets/784/10784/Ener...

[2] https://offgridquest.com/images/banners/gravitybattery.png

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by stainforth on Friday July 17, 2020 @05:45PM (#23876222)
[1] Echoes Tower of Hanoi, slightly interesting
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by jes5199 on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:25PM (#23873019)
theoretically yes, but we have to scale production way up, there just aren't enough batteries in the world right now
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pfdietz on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:23AM (#23871514)
Solar and wind and storage can supply 100% of the grid more cheaply than a CO2-free solution also using newly constructed nuclear. Many nuclear advocates still don't understand this new reality.
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pas on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:20PM (#23872954)
The problem is, currently there is not enough economic activity spent on storage (or any CO2-neutral thing really). You probably know the numbers. To switch off CO2 emissions we would need to build CO2-free power plants about 10 per day for 10 years.

Total US electricity generated by nuclear power plants was about 807 TWh (~92GW), but just in 2010 the world used 41 354 TWh generated by coal. That's a factor of 50. The US has about 95 commercial plants. So to replace just coal we'd need about 4750 new power stations.

Basically at this point everything that's not fossil based is great. Build all of them. More wind, solar, storage, nuclear, geo, etc.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by philipkglass on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:45PM (#23873967)
The problem is huge, but not quite as grim as this. I think that you may be confusing primary (thermal) energy in coal with electricity supplied by coal. In 2018, coal was used to generate about 10,000 TWh of electricity:

https://www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-outlook-2019/electr...

Renewable generators only need to displace the electrical output of combustion based power plants, not the greater thermal energy contained in source fuels. A highly electrified, renewables-dominated world would consume less primary energy at the same level of energy service consumption. There's a lot less energy going toward production of useless waste heat when renewable electricity displaces fossil combustion electricity.

The average American coal plant turns only 37.4% of coal's thermal energy into electrical energy:

https://processbarron.com/u-s-coal-power-plant-efficiency-st...

In 2019 the United States lost 2/3 of all primary energy as waste heat:

https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/content/assets/images/charts/Ene...

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pas on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:18PM (#23875033)
Thanks for the correction, alas the edit period has closed for that comment.

(I used the number from this wiki page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_consumption#Fossi... )

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by macspoofing on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:38AM (#23871679)
>Solar and wind and storage

What storage? The reality is that there is no storage solution that is capable of storing enough energy to power even a modestly sized city for days or even hours (or minutes for that matter). Certain approaches, like gravity-based storage, also require particular geography.

Did you notice that there is no region on earth that gets 100% of their power from solar/wind/storage? Why is that? Why is Germany signing multi-decade, mulit-billion-dollar deals to build pipelines to ship Russian gas for decades still? And any region that claims 100% fossil-fuel free power ALWAYS relies on hydro, nuclear or geothermal to achieve that level. Why is that?

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pfdietz on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:53AM (#23871852)
Diurnal storage via batteries or pumped hydro, long term storage via hydrogen. The combinations now optimize to 0% nuclear. Hydrogen round trip efficiency is low but the very low cost per kWh of storage capacity makes it win for long term storage.

That no location is currently 100% renewable is an obviously irrelevant point. I m talking about 100% CO2-free solutions. And new nuclear not sunk costed existing power plants.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by macspoofing on Friday July 17, 2020 @12:02PM (#23871952)
You're just throwing things against the barn door hoping something sticks. Every proponent of renewables has a favorite miraculous battery technology that solves the intermittency problem. And yet I look at world, and nobody has actually deployed any storage technology at scale (and by 'scale', I mean using some battery technology that stores enough energy to power a modestly sized city of a few hundred thousands people for even a few hours).
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pfdietz on Friday July 17, 2020 @12:11PM (#23872064)
What I'm adding here is not miraculous new battery technology. It's hydrogen for long term storage. All the components of that exist and are proven. It's just a matter of integrating them. This is the most reliable and easiest kind of innovation, and it's the death knell for nuclear.
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by macspoofing on Friday July 17, 2020 @12:26PM (#23872266)
Why hasn't it been deployed thus far? Is anyone planning to deploy it? Are there ongoing projects to deploy it at scale?

> All the components of that exist and are proven.

All the components for solar roadways and hyperloop exist and are proven, doesn't mean either of those are viable.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pfdietz on Friday July 17, 2020 @12:38PM (#23872402)
> Why hasn't it been deployed thus far?

For three straightforward reasons:

(1) Wind and (especially) solar have only recently become cheap enough for this case to be made. Utility scale solar fell in cost by a factor of 5 in just the last decade,

(2) The point I made was for an apples-to-apples comparison in which all the capital costs are considered. But in this transition time the renewables are competing against existing capacity, in which the capital costs are sunk,

(3) Fossil fuel sources are not being charged for their CO2 emissions. The point I made was for a CO2-free grid, which requires that fossil fuel sources not be allowed to emit CO2. Nowhere have CO2 taxes or regulations yet put us into this situation.

Today, there are very few, if any, places in the world where it would make economic sense to build a new nuclear power plant.

> All the components for solar roadways and hyperloop exist and are proven, doesn't mean either of those are viable.

Electrolyzers exist, and are being made and sold in rapidly increasing numbers. Hydrogen valves, compressors, turbines, pipelines, and underground storage caverns exist. This is integration of existing technologies, some with track records going back more than a century. The comparison you make there is silly in the extreme. It would be more appropriate if applied to the current hype about thorium and Hail Mary Reactors.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by macspoofing on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:17PM (#23872924)
>For three straightforward reasons

There's a fourth reason ... it isn't viable.

And for all the talk about how the technology is ready and proven, you can't even point me to a real-world deployment, existing or planned, that will provide storage at any sort of scale to replace natural gas as wind/solar backup.

Actions speak louder than words. Take Germany for example, why aren't they redirecting the billions they are spending on NEW natural gas pipelines to ship Russian gas for decades, on your 'proven' and 'ready' battery storage technology?

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pfdietz on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:36PM (#23873876)
And you have not refuted the explanation I gave for why there was not a deployment yet. That explanation is why the argument you are sticking to there is nonsense.

Your last question there has the answer "because the cost of CO2 in Europe is not high enough yet." Hydrogen doesn't make sense until natural gas is quite expensive, but even then a renewable system with hydrogen will be cheaper than a CO2-free system with fully costed nuclear.

Are you employed by the nuclear industry, by any chance? If so, if you aren't too old, run do not walk to another career.

Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by ozim on Friday July 17, 2020 @12:54PM (#23872619)
Parent mentions pumped hydro like that can be setup anywhere in the world.
Re:The end of the Arab world’s oil age is nigh by pfdietz on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:03PM (#23872739)
"or"