News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by netcan on Friday July 17, 2020 @08:22AM (#23869715)
>I'm not sure I'm identifying the race they are referring to correctly (too many History Channel documentaries maybe). For example, I don't think the Hebrews are supposed to have had a homeland at that point in history.

The relationships between biblical accounts of pre-classical periods is necessarily shaky. The pre-kingdom parts of the bible read very much like mythology, metaphor and heroic ancestor tales.

That said, there are various points of intersection or allusion to actual known history. The migration of the Hyksos could relate to the biblical story of Joseph. It's basically an account of migration from Canaan to Egypt because of a famine. Like the article said, there do seem to have been migrations to egypt of various semitic people. The hyksos are the best known of them.

Exodus relates to a later period. It's a story of a semitic slave migration out of egypt, becoming an independent nomadic tribe in canaan, midia & sinai. Historically, egypt had just lost these territories and receded to its core territory. Among many chaotic things happening, egypt was in conflict with various barbarian tribes from these regions...

It's not that solid historical accounts from egypt confirm the biblical narrative. They make almost no reference to hebrews, escaped slaves, etc. But, the biblical account does make some sort of sense.

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by nobleach on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:36AM (#23870936)
I've been fascinated by this argument for a few years. An "ask a historian" thread on Reddit asked an important question: "Would a kingdom, that chased slaves out of Egypt, only to be met with massive defeat, record that history?". I know nothing about Egyptology, so I'd ask, "did Egyptians, as a general rule, record any of their defeats?" From my limited Google searches, they did not. So the question becomes, is there any evidence of semitic people living in Egypt. That seems to be argued a bit more.
Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by netcan on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:40AM (#23871696)
There is lots of evidence of semitic people in egypt over various periods. Also egyptian conquests & long lived administrations in these regions.

"Semitic," as a language group is pretty big. There are also semitic languages spoken to the south of egypt, who were also interacting a lot with egypt.

The Egyptians glorified their history like any political culture does, but massive defeats don't go unrecorded. They just make them seem like wins.^ In the relevant period, egypt (and the whole region) went through extreme instability. Historians don't totally understand it, and people then may not have either. But, there's lots of historical record of chaos and defeat. There are even surviving letters between besieged nobles candidly admitting major losses.

I think it's more likely that exodus was just a much bigger deal to the Israelites than it was to Egyptians. To Egypt, it was no big deal. If Pharoah really had witnessed the sea part, and an angry god destroying his army... there would be a relief. Egyptians recorded noteworthy events.

That said, it was a declining period and the egyptian record is patchy during these times.

^EG https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Seev%C3%B6lker.jpg#/...

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by KMag on Saturday July 18, 2020 @09:53PM (#23886365)
By "there would be a relief", I presume you mean "they would have created a relief sculpture", rather than "they would have felt emotional relief". As written the sentence is ambiguous, and right at the point where you pivot from evidence supporting the slave escape narrative to evidence contradicting the slave escape narrative, so I can't be certain my reading is correct despite it fitting much better with the following sentence.
Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by netcan on Sunday July 19, 2020 @04:33AM (#23887919)
Yes. I meant statuary, obviously. I also meant it as a joke.
Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by eternalban on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:21PM (#23872981)
Pre-Kingdom? David and Solomon are larger than life figures in bible but afaik no contemporary neighbor recorded their existence. They are historic ghosts. Pure fiction.
Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by throwawayexodus on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:15PM (#23878594)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tel_Dan_stele https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Yahudu_Tablets

This comes up so often in these debates! I think there's way too much archaeological evidence on the ground to deny the reality of the Davidic Monarchy.

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by netcan on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:15PM (#23873637)
Sure. I didn't mean to draw a hard line.

The monarchic period, even David and Solomon, reads a lot more political writing. The region enters into a historical period. The biblical stories start to relate more definitely to known historical events.

David and Solomon are kind of transitional, it's really just gradual. It gets more mythical as you go back.

Immediately following from the solomon period, the bible is referencing known assyrian emperors, pharaohs, and reporting on conquests that are historically known. There are dates.

By the end of the kingdom period, it's already the babylonian era... At that point it's basically modernity.

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by eternalban on Friday July 17, 2020 @02:29PM (#23873797)
Actually, as a student of Iranian history, those "Babylonian" era records are rather intriguing, to say the least. It seems to me Judaism (and associated myths) are a product of an aborted imperial social engineering project of the aborted first Persian Empire. Even the historic divide of religious Jews and "Greek Jews" reflects the sudden collapse of the first Persian Empire and its replacement by the Greeks.

A reading of relevant biblical texts strongly suggests that the 'returnees' from Babylon were alien to whoever was living in Jerusalem. And the religion they brought back smacks of Zoroastrianism in its theological contours. Heaven, hell, resurrection, judgment, angels, and good and evil: these are Iranian elements. (Egypt also had judgment, heaven, and hell.) It took a few attempts to get the inhabitants to change their religion -- it's in the book, as they say, so don't take my word for it.

Those famous boundaries of lands promised to Abraham, for example, which stop right at the border of historic Greater Iran and Egypt, are basically the boundaries of the project 'temple state' the Persians attempted to create as a prepatory step to conquering Egypt. Heck, the Persian Emperor is even specially called "Messiah" (Divine King) in Isa. 45.

It is my opinion (and just that) that the sudden cessation of [imported Jewish] religious leaders from Babylon -- a seat of Persian Empire at that time lest we forget -- due to the collapse of the empire, is the basis of the mutatation of the work-in-progress so that the "divine mandate" of the famous Abrahamic lands were now in fact given by none other than "GOD" itself.

The irony of course, is the blowback of this Persian Imperial project 2500 years later.

[minor corrective edits]

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by netcan on Saturday July 18, 2020 @01:53AM (#23879348)
If you are interested in this subject, look into samaritans.

They are a closely related group to jews, but probably had less Babylonian & Persian influence. Their version of the Torah ends with Solomon. To this day, they maintain a religion similar to old temple judaism. High priest, sacrifice, etc. Their Torah is written in the native hebrew script. Jews switched to an assyrian script at some point.

Nehemiah (book in the bible) was the first pacha, persian governor of jerusalem. Religious & conservative fanatic, persecuting samaritans and annulling mixed marriages.

In any case, the samaritan torah has the same account of abraham as the jewish bible. It's still possible that Persian or Babylonian beliefs & characters were adopted, especially abraham. But, that would have had to happen long before cyrus. Samaritans also have abraham and the divine land grant.

I assume you mean the "nile to euphrates" boundary. It's actually very hard to tell what those parts are about. First, it's not actually clear those are the rivers... especially the nile. Second, there are no other passages that relate to this territory. Nehemia doesn't mention or pursue them.

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by eternalban on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @02:42PM (#23990174)
Sorry for the late reply to your very interesting post.

I fully agree that ancient levantine figures, such as Noah, Job, and Abraham, predate the Persian era and were likely incorporated in Babylon.

Have to look into this Hebrew Samaritan Torah you mentioned. My understanding was that there were -no- extant torah of any kind at the time when the people came from Babylon claiming themselves to be the exiles. I know they presecuted the Samaritans to assert their own (version of) religion.

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by ncmncm on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:48PM (#23875358)
I have seen suggestions that the early Hebrew kings are re-branded pharaohs: Akhenaten and Nefertiti as (sequence-displaced) mono-theistic Adam and Eve, Solomon's gold as southern Egyptian tribute, Song of Solomon cribbed from an Egyptian prayer, maybe even a pyramid as Ararat. Nothing conclusive that I know of, but intriguing hints.
Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by eternalban on Friday July 17, 2020 @05:04PM (#23875539)
I'm entirely off the current mainstream interpretation of Akhenaten. Akhenaten, to me, was hardly a "monotheist". In fact, if I were asked to name a historic figure that was the famous pharoah of biblical lore (the anti-Moses) I would unhesitatingly point to Akhenaten. I suggest considering his treatment of 'temple' with the pre-existing Egyptian norm. His temple has no roof. The original Egyptian model reflected the canonical Macro-Micro duality and was in fact a 'closed' space. Akhenaten, per my reading, claimed that he was the incarnate 'one god'. No wonder the Egyptians erased all traces of his reign after his demise. They totally erased him from Egyptian records. Something to think about. (Egyptians were certainly 'godly'. Just review the Egyptian prayers of the dead.)

   O sole god, like whom there is no other!   
   Thou didst create the world according to thy desire
That is a prayer from ancient Egypt.

That said, the idea that Hebrew mythological kings are in fact borrowings of Egyptian glory makes a lot of sense. Some of the imagery -- tributes being brought from far away lands to Solomon -- however is distinctly reminiscent of Persepolis.

https://thumbs.dreamstime.com/z/relief-depicting-procession-...

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by netcan on Saturday July 18, 2020 @02:30AM (#23879507)
My interpretation is more banal.

The borrowings are more superficial. We know that language and style used to describe kings, emperors, and gods are very similar. The "I am Sargon, King of Kings" style occurs in political and religious writings all throughout the region... with roots going deep into the bronze age.

Recurring imagery, writing style, motifs, titles, etc. are the norm. Lots of cultural elements are broadly found throughout the greater region. It's not surprising that they'd exist in any two traditions. All these traditions affected eachother.

Take the Sphinx motif, Seraphim in temple judaism. It's a motif found very widely, over a very long period of time. The imagery is reused. The symbolism is reused. It's impossible to draw a clear path of progression though.

On monotheism... I don't think monotheism is all that significant, per se. Whatever the origins of this were, canaanite cities and kings were clearly being closely associated to single deities. One king, one god. Maybe one temple. That was a typical mode. Is that monotheism? Why care, outside of theology?

What is significant about monotheism is not monotheism. It's the "jealous god," the strict prohibitions on "foreign worship." This exclusionism is what made the religion so successful in the long term. We see this even in modern times. Religions that tolerate multiple belief systems give way to monotheism.

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by KMag on Saturday July 18, 2020 @10:10PM (#23886452)
FYI, the name for the jealous god among many gods is "monolatry". Historically, monolatry has a strong tendency to morph into monotheism, as it's much more stable belief system vs. having solid reasons not to worship other gods on the side.

In the Bible, there's evidence that the earliest Judaism was monolatrist[0]. You can see a very long period of frustration the priests have with people mostly worshipping the most powerful god, but hedging their bets with side worship of Baal Zebul, Asherah, etc. despite Yahweh's jealousy. They had a much easier time discouraging the side worship once they started asserting those side gods didn't exist, rather than saying they were dramatically less powerful.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monolatry#In_ancient_Israel

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by netcan on Sunday July 19, 2020 @05:00AM (#23888011)
So... to my perspective, monolatry is the point. Monotheism is a good enough approximation in practice though.

Also, it's not the idea of monolatry or monotheism that matters... it's the development of a religious culture than is effective at banning other religions. This is what made monotheism what it is, historically.

Re:Who were the Hyksos? Strontium isotope analysis of remain... by ncmncm on Saturday July 18, 2020 @09:39AM (#23881327)
What I have seen of Akhenaten has him representing Aten, the Sun god.

We have a great deal of material on him (or rather on what he chose to have carved) despite erasure from records, because his capital was abandoned immediately after his death.