News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Auto submission bots on Hacker News by mzl on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:40AM (#2386917)
Thanks. That comment was my biggest hitting one ever, so my average will probably jump quite a bit. Funny that it should be in a meta-karma thread.

I do see what you mean, I didn't think you were discarding comments from low karma commenters. I mostly wanted to bring up a point that is often missed in these discussions, that karma points might be very dependent on not only participation and quality, but on timing.

Given that using average karma as a filter is so blunt, an alternative way to express your method would be "I might see a high average karma as a reason to re-evaluate a comment that I initially discarded". Then it would be even harder to misconstrue into something sinister and karma elitist as I did :)

* Edit: from the comment below by mrduncan that shows how average calculation is done, my previous comment will not affect my average a lot. The max comment is sensibly ignored as a potential outlier.

Re:Auto submission bots on Hacker News by khafra on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @02:48PM (#2388609)
You started me thinking about ways to normalize average karma, but I haven't come up with one that makes me happy yet:

- adjusting to other comments on the same post doesn't account for timing

- adjusting for time after the post is gameable by necromancers

- adjusting by the total karma of the post commented on is incomplete; it also needs some relation to the time lapse from posting to comment

- penalizing short comments might help discourage snarky one-liners

Are there browser plugins to give an adjusted average karma score this way, yet?