Re:Don't Panic! Better, Fewer, Syntax Errors for LR Parsers
by choeger on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:55AM
(#23856802)
There are way more parsers out there in production than the top-ten programming language implementations. Just think about serialization formats (json, bson, protobuff, et.al.): There are maybe 10 or so widely used. Then think about message formats (http, xml, yaml, ...): Maybe another 10 or so? Then think about configuration languages (.ini, .toml, ...), let's call that 5?. On top of that we have a bunch of widely used scripting languages (Make, sh, various lisps), I would say again 5 or so.
So for any new language, say rust, you want (ideally) parsers for about 30 or more languages in real-world use cases. And that does not include language prototyping or consider the fact that recursive-descent parsers are usually not available as libraries (say for use in an editor).
In conclusion: Having good automatic parser generators readily available is very relevant. And "good" can obviosly include usability, IMO.
So for any new language, say rust, you want (ideally) parsers for about 30 or more languages in real-world use cases. And that does not include language prototyping or consider the fact that recursive-descent parsers are usually not available as libraries (say for use in an editor).
In conclusion: Having good automatic parser generators readily available is very relevant. And "good" can obviosly include usability, IMO.