Re:FBI wants public help solving encrypted notes from murder...
by caf on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @08:30PM
(#2385212)
It could just mean that it's a transposition-only cipher.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:FBI wants public help solving encrypted notes from murder...
by dandelany on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @09:37PM
(#2385388)
Exactly. To clarify: a transposition cipher is one that just scrambles the letters in the plaintext according to some algorithm to get the ciphertext, which would cause you to get the same letter frequencies as the plaintext.
The problem is figuring out the rules of transposition so you can reverse them to decipher. There are tons of possibilities and you can't exactly plug a corpus this large into an anagram solver...
That said, the fact that there are also several repeated sections ("words") does make me wonder if it's a hoax, that's not something I'd expect to see with a transposition cipher, unless the transposition rules somehow preserved repetition in passages?
Anyway, food for thought.