In most cases companies have a ball park salary in mind for the position, so when it comes time to convert there is some room for negotiation, but no surprises.
Companies are so desperate for good software engineers that they aren't going to let a good dev go after several months on contract in order to low-ball you and save a few thousand dollars.
I'm almost willing to believe this works for people who absolutely are unable to pass any sort of interview, but in that case aren't they still in trouble? How does a company decide who to bring on for the contract? Surely you can't replace the interview process with this.
That does not conform to my experience as employee or as an employer. Do you have any evidence to support it? If does sound like something a recruiter who wants to take a cut of your first year salary (from the employer) would say.
Negotiating your salary upfront is likely going to give you the best deal you can get. Don't kid yourself into thinking that you can "show your value" to improve your negotiating position. Your first few months on the job are usually when you are at your lowest performance, since you are learning the company's processes. That is your trial period.
You are in your best negotiating position when the company needs you more than you need them, and that is absolutely NOT after doing contract work for them for a while.
Once you're at the point of converting, if you get a lowball offer, the contract position is a black mark on your resume that hurts your negotiating position with other firms.
That said, I would be happy to do C2H if the following conditions were met:
* Signing bonus paid in full at point of signing the contract, with no clawback.
* Full health coverage during the contract portion (extra money plus the option to buy from their plans).
* Severance pay at full salary for at least 6 months if you choose not to convert.
* Non-exclusivity during the contract period (I can do other work if I want, and you don't own any IP I produce other than what I produce explicitly for you).
I think this is sufficient to equalize the negotiating disadvantage that I get for taking the contract. I don't think any of your clients would go for it.