News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dabblers and Blowhards - A Criticism of PG by startingup on Monday July 07, 2008 @03:24AM (#238402)
Well, in that case, the title of the book "Hackers and Painters", overstates the connection.

As a programmer who has had some success and money (and not a painter, not a musician, in fact, not well-endowed in any of the arts, but with a fairly decent math background), I have to say that I found the connection tenuous too. Not to say I don't agree with PG on most things - I actually do.

If I were to write a book I would say "Hackers & Thinkers" because that's what I do with my time - think about things.

Re:Dabblers and Blowhards - A Criticism of PG by cglee on Monday July 07, 2008 @05:59AM (#238466)
I don't see how linking hacking and thinking brings any new insight. It's pretty obvious the two are connected. Hacking and painting is a more interesting cross-pollination.

The title "Hackers and Painters", in my opinion, doesn't overstate anything - it's an appropriate title, out of many, for the essay.

Re:Dabblers and Blowhards - A Criticism of PG by startingup on Monday July 07, 2008 @06:15AM (#238474)
I said "Hackers and Thinkers" just to illustrate the point that we tend to overemphasize our own particular areas of interest. Hacking and thinking don't have to go together - as an example, PG is a thinker who writes essays, but there exist many great hackers who don't spend much time thinking about general stuff. They tend to be fairly narrowly focused.