News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by strombofulous on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:35PM (#23837493)
I have lots of friends who play shooting games semi-competitvely (they're all in the very high ranks of overwatch/csgo/etc). They are all very, very, very excited about Valorant's ring-0 anticheat. Lots of people want features that can't be achieved with a sandbox.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:41PM (#23837558)
I definitely understand that. Cheaters have pushed me out of most first-person shooters I'd enjoyed. But I also have significant concerns about game companies having that much access to my general-use computer.

Perhaps the solution here is not to do personal/sensitive work on gaming machines, but then we're right back to having separate game consoles...

Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by jhardy54 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:47PM (#23837619)
Alternatively: Only play video games with people in your trust network. Friends, friends of friends, etc., so that you have some recourse against griefing and cheating.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:02PM (#23837816)
This doesn't really help: I don't have a choice on whether or not my shooter of choice implements anti-cheat.

Perhaps an ideal scenario would let a player choose whether or not to enable a game's anti-cheat, but that it'd be required for certain matchmaking and (obviously) competitive features. So that I can opt out if I'm just trying the game casually or just playing with friends in a private room, but can enable it if it's something I intend to play seriously and am invested in enough to give deep access to my system?

Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by joosters on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:47PM (#23837620)
If you implement the sandboxing very thoroughly and only permit signed code to run, you can make it even more difficult to cheat. e.g. on iOS, it would be very hard to change the client code of a multiplayer game without being detected.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by ubercow13 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:50PM (#23837656)
How would that work on a general purpose computer?
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by joosters on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:13PM (#23837981)
The technology is just about here today. If your PC has secure boot, you can theoretically lock it down to only allow booting a suitably restrictive OS, which then is responsible for restricting the apps and games that can run & the permissions they have. Lots of layers of signed code checking, really.

The main weakness (other than code vulnerabilities) is the network: it's very difficult to guarantee that a remote computer is running the allowed OS & game code, and not a hacked version. However, technologies like Intel's SGX x86 extensions can make this possible: because of the added encryption in the core CPU, one machine can send a cryptographic challenge to another one, and it can only respond correctly if the remote CPU has validated the code it is executing.

So, the tech is there. But in reality, people really don't want to lock down their PCs so securely and effectively give full control to their OS vendor.

Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by outworlder on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:07PM (#23837892)
The same way "anti-cheat" software already works today? With the addition of a sandbox running signed code, which is yet another barrier.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by weehoo on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:43PM (#23837578)
Ring zero doesn’t prevent cheats stored in spoofed input devices

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=d1jz8qbzfIk

Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by falcolas on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:49PM (#23837646)
And like virus scanners, it can't recognize anything it doesn't already have a signature for.

But, it could upload "suspicious" data to the home servers to be evaluated and fed into the signature database. Just like any other feedback loop in anti-cheat (and anti-virus) systems, only this one can access everything on your system.

Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by Kaze404 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:54PM (#23837713)
Does it actually work though? What's stopping me from running the game in a virtual machine with GPU-passthrough and emulating inputs?
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by ubercow13 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:56PM (#23837752)
It's quite hard to hide the fact you're running in a VM, if possible at all. I think Valorant refuses to run in a VM.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by Kaze404 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:04PM (#23837851)
Interesting. I actually have a GPU-passthrough and regularly play a japanese MMO with a similarly invasive rootkit. I haven't actually tried Valorant, but I might when I have some time out of curiosity.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by ubercow13 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:06PM (#23837881)
I think up to now, despite how easy it is to detect, anticheat has largely ignored VMs. Valorant is noteable for being the first game widely reported to refuse running in a VM.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by Kaze404 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:28PM (#23838161)
I don't think they've ignored VMs. In fact the very game I mentioned before refuses to run in VMWare and VirtualBox, even though I've managed to run it on Qemu out of the box. Though I'm not sure if it's incompetence or they just don't care :p
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by dylz on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:30PM (#23838187)
Many Asian MMOs block VM execution, namely mostly anything by GameGuard/HackShield/XIGNCODE.
Re:Doom Eternal Privacy Policy Allows Collection and Disclos... by Rebelgecko on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:14PM (#23837996)
Valorant doesn't even like my legit Intel CPU drivers