News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by mariodiana on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:58PM (#23836988)
I'm not a lawyer, but how is it Harvard and MIT had standing in court for this case?
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by charonn0 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:42PM (#23837566)
> 19. Plaintiffs have standing to bring this case. Defendants’ actions will cause an imminent, concrete, and irreparable risk to Plaintiffs’ ability to achieve their educational missions unless halted by this Court.

> 20.Plaintiffs also have standing to assert claims on behalf of their F-1 visa-holding students, who face the imminent, concrete, and irreparable risk of harm to themselves, their families, their educations, their short-term and long-term health, and their future education and employment prospects if Defendants’ actions are not halted by this Court.

[0]: https://www.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/content/sevp_fil...

Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by gnulinux on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:32PM (#23838209)
Others gave you good answers but also consider this. There are thousands of PhD students who create value for these universities. They not only do research, help research being made, they also teach others. Kicking all these people out of US due to whims of ICE harms universities' financial interest as well. Universities are not making their education remote because they choose to do so. They're doing precisely to protect students and faculty. It's capricious for ICE to see this and conclude "if you do that then I'll kick all your students out of this country". Universities invest in PhD students, they're part of faculty.
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by gwright on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @06:26PM (#23838809)
FWIW, it is helpful to understand that this isn't ICE making policy randomly but in fact just enforcing the regulations surrounding student visas. The existing regulations were relaxed in March but the underlying regulatory idea is that you don't need a visa for online education and online education is not sufficient for a visa to be issued.

I tend to think that it was premature to rescind the temporary waiving of the oversight regulations, but that isn't the same thing as saying the underlying regulations don't have a rationale basis.

Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by gnulinux on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @06:40PM (#23838963)
(AINAL) No I don't think you're correct, which is what I (and others) were trying to explain. Which is also why MIT and Harvard (and many other universities) sued ICE. Here, copy paste from another comment:

> 19. Plaintiffs have standing to bring this case. Defendants’ actions will cause an imminent, concrete, and irreparable risk to Plaintiffs’ ability to achieve their educational missions unless halted by this Court.

> 20.Plaintiffs also have standing to assert claims on behalf of their F-1 visa-holding students, who face the imminent, concrete, and irreparable risk of harm to themselves, their families, their educations, their short-term and long-term health, and their future education and employment prospects if Defendants’ actions are not halted by this Court.

[0]: https://www.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/content/sevp_fil...

What you're missing is universities are making their classes online not because they're offering online education, but because they're forced to do so in order to protect students and faculty (including F1 students) from a pandemic. F1 visa specifically gives students right to protect themselves from such risks.

If universities switched to remote education e.g. to cut cost or to experiment with online education methods, then you'd be right. But the argument here is that universities do this because students and faculty face irreparable damage or death, and therefore there is no basis to deport to F1 students.

Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by gwright on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @09:05PM (#23840083)
I tend to agree with you but I don't think your argument contradicts my statement. You are basically arguing that the health emergency still exists and the exemption should remain. I think that is a defensible argument, but that doesn't mean that the underlying logic (you don't need a visa to take an online course load) is invalid. If the health argument went away you would still be left with that underlying logic.
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by gnulinux on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @09:48AM (#23845149)
Yes, I think we agree.
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by aspaceman on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:19PM (#23837275)
IAANAL but I think since they were demonstrably harmed by the policy, they can file suit against it.
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:03PM (#23837062)
They sued partially on behalf of their students, and they also stood to lose a lot of tuition money themselves.
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by wittyreference on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:00PM (#23837030)
They are reliant on these students for income. They are directly harmed by the policy. Therefore, standing?
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by amerine on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:59PM (#23837012)
Why wouldn’t they? Your question doesn’t make sense to me
Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by oh_sigh on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:26PM (#23837365)
You can't just sue because you are displeased with something - you need to have suffered, or will suffer direct harm from the thing(this is called locus standi). I'm guessing OP is saying that Harvard/MIT would not be harmed from this, only the students would be harmed(so they would need to be the ones to sue, not the college).

It kind of makes sense - if everything is online courses, it doesn't matter to Harvard whether the students are at an apartment in Cambridge St or in the middle of the Mongolian steppe, as long as you have internet access.

On the other hand, if students are deciding to attend some other university(say, one in their home country) and Harvard can show that harms them, then they would have standing

Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by paxys on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @06:44PM (#23839006)
> It kind of makes sense - if everything is online courses, it doesn't matter to Harvard whether the students are at an apartment in Cambridge St or in the middle of the Mongolian steppe, as long as you have internet access.

It makes a massive difference.

1. Students need good internet access, which a lot of them don't have in third world countries.

2. Students can't be expected to attend lectures and participate in class when they are in an opposite timezone (i.e. all of India and China).

It's a pretty easy decision for all of these students to just skip a semester rather than pay ridiculous tuition and not even be allowed to stay on campus, hence causing problems for the university.

Re:U.S. backs down in fight with Harvard, MIT over student v... by afarrell on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @06:14PM (#23838677)
Making a company's employees (grad students) suddenly move continents from a place they'd been living for 3 years is a pretty big harm.