News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @11:56AM (#23833421)
> All this bodes ill, especially for independent-minded young writers and editors paying close attention to what they’ll have to do to advance in their careers. Rule One: Speak your mind at your own peril. Rule Two: Never risk commissioning a story that goes against the narrative. Rule Three: Never believe an editor or publisher who urges you to go against the grain. Eventually, the publisher will cave to the mob, the editor will get fired or reassigned, and you’ll be hung out to dry.

It is supremely ironic for a famous writer, employed for years at America's paper of record, to complain about being silenced by her critics in a resignation letter that will be shared far and wide and read by tens — if not hundreds — of thousands of people.

Re:Resignation Letter by seibelj on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:03PM (#23833534)
This is the latest argument from people who claim cancel culture doesn't exist. "How are you being silenced when everyone will read it from your high perch?"

High-level writers need to push back against illiberal and anti-free speech proponents to give cover for the lower ranks. If even the top tier writers can't speak their mind, does the lowly intern or new hire stand a chance?

Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:15PM (#23833739)
The problem with this rebuttal is that it assumes that the high–level writers and editors are not themselves the illiberal and anti–speech proponents, gatekeeping what perspectives are allowed to be represented in the first place.

For example: Harper's Magazine, which published the recent open letter on cancel culture that Bari Weiss signed, doesn't pay its interns [1], ensuring that only those who can afford to work for free are allowed on the lowest rung of the ladder. If these high–level writers were truly concerned about open debate and a culture of curiosity, they might be more concerned about breaking down barriers such as that. Instead, they're worried that they, the people already at the top of the ladder, might get knocked down to the same level as the rest of us.

[1] https://harpers.org/about/internships/

Re:Resignation Letter by seibelj on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:23PM (#23833890)
Rather than criticize the content of the letter, you attack Harper's for not paying interns, which is unrelated to the content. Classic tactic for silencing disagreement is to attack the source.

What do you disagree with in the Harper's letter itself (the content, not the publication or the signatories), and why?

Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:36PM (#23834114)
Initially, I was criticizing the content, which is on its face false: we are discussing multiple widely–read pieces from prominent people who claim they are being "canceled" for their views.

You claimed that they are speaking out for the benefit of less powerful writers. Since the goalposts have shifted to their intentions, attacking the source is absolutely relevant. I simply don't believe those intentions, given that these are people who themselves have prevented many diverse points of view from being heard in the first place.

Re:Resignation Letter by istjohn on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:26PM (#23834903)
How have the authors prevented many diverse points of view from being heard? You're going to need more than "they signed onto an open letter published in a magazine that has unpaid interns."
Re:Resignation Letter by seibelj on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:49PM (#23834352)
What do you disagree with in the Harper's letter itself (the content, not the publication or the signatories), and why?

I assume you also support the letter, if it had appeared in a publication you approved of?

Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:58PM (#23834490)
Again:

> Initially, I was criticizing the content, which is on its face false: we are discussing multiple widely–read pieces from prominent people who claim they are being "canceled" for their views.

If Alice makes a claim about herself, it is not "attacking the source" to say the claim is false. That also doesn't mean that the same claim would be false if Bob made it about himself.

So, yes: if smaller writers who had actually been marginalized or excluded wrote an open letter claiming as much in a publication with a track record of publishing such voices, I might have supported it, because their claims might have actually been credible.

Instead, a publication that works to homogenize journalism published a letter signed by powerful writers about how they are being "silenced". By virtue of the fact that millions of people are now discussing their views, that claim is self–evidently false.

Re:Resignation Letter by seibelj on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:39PM (#23835069)
It sounds like you are immediately suspect of anyone who has had success and thus become "powerful" (successful). The signatories of the Harper's letter, such as Noam Chomsky, Thomas Chatterton Williams, and Salman Rushdie, are successful because they have had long careers and widespread general praise for their work. Smaller, newer writers aren't "marginalized", they are early in their careers and need to work for a long time to break out in a cutthroat industry.

The signatories of the letter make the person who disagrees with the current orthodoxy, and still supports free speech, feel safer and in good company for doing so. Signing a letter is quick and doesn't stop them from also helping solve all the other issues they believe in - people can do two (or more!) things at once.

I am a lot less interested in political statements from people - you, me, the guy down the street - who are not luminaries in their respected fields. I am much more interested when such a diverse and respected group of people have those views.

As a footnote, you say "might have supported it". Imagine hypothetically that it was published in some underground zine signed by unknown writers. What in the letter did you disagree with? It's a brief letter, there should be something in there that is clearly risque if you "might" support it?

Re:Resignation Letter by joshuamorton on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:34PM (#23834075)
The content ignores context of the discussion. Lies by omission are still lies, and trying to ignore them is bad faith to those who recognize them.
Re:Resignation Letter by koheripbal on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:59PM (#23835329)
wow... you are literally embodying the cancel culture by claiming that their opinion is irrelevant because of some HR pay practice you discovered that is totally orthogonal to the conversation?

Should we cancel your opinion because of some seemingly inconsistent opinion you had in your comment history?

This is exactly the practice of arguing the arguer, rather than the argument, and it's a bad faith tactic.

Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:37PM (#23838271)
> This is exactly the practice of arguing the arguer, rather than the argument, and it's a bad faith tactic.

Her claim is that she, herself, is being exceptionally victimized and silenced; it’s literally impossible rebut this without arguing against her, specifically.

Harper’s’ unpaid internships was a more general example. Had I been speaking about Bari Weiss specifically, I might have mentioned her support for deplatforming a Jewish speaker from Stanford [1], her attempts to get Arab professors fired [2] or her reports to other employees’ bosses in response to minor slights [3].

And even if my argument were to hinge on an orthogonal claim, you think that’s tantamount to “embodying cancel culture”? I haven’t called for any personal or professional consequences; literally all I’m doing is disagreeing with her.

This is why so many roll their eyes when people start waxing on about cancel culture. What they really mean is that they don’t want to hear criticism of their opinions.

[1] https://twitter.com/bariweiss/status/1125789271959277569?s=2...

[2] https://theintercept.com/2018/03/08/the-nyts-bari-weiss-fals...

[3] https://twitter.com/byjoelanderson/status/126865430820500684...

Re:Resignation Letter by PunchTornado on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @12:25PM (#23847516)
no, they want people to get fired and lose sources of revenue. Look what's happening with uncle bob on twitter. Plenty of examples where people are kicked of conferences for wearing a red hat https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21484676 Jordan Peterson gets his offer to teach at Cambridge University rejected after a twitter cancel culture mob started attacking the Uni.

You are chosing to ignore the cancel culture that exists.

Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @12:59PM (#23848024)
You misunderstand me: the people complaining about “cancel culture” are the ones who simply want to be able to air their opinions without hearing criticism.

I don’t know what’s happening to Uncle Bob on Twitter, but right now his account has 150,000 followers. So, what consequences is he actually suffering here?

What if you switched out the MAGA hat for one bearing the rebel flag or a misogynistic slur? It seems eminently reasonable to me for a conference to kick people out for refusing to remove a superfluous article of clothing that makes other attendees feel unwelcome.

Jordan Peterson’s offer was rescinded not because of a “twitter cancel culture mob” but by students and faculty at the University, who absolutely have a right to decide whom to allow into their community: https://www.theguardian.com/education/2019/mar/20/cambridge-...

Re:Resignation Letter by PunchTornado on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:17PM (#23872913)
the firing of David Shor, a data analyst at the progressive consulting firm Civis Analytics. Amid the protests over Floyd’s killing, Shor was called out online for tweeting about work by Omar Wasow, an assistant professor of politics at Princeton, that shows a link between violent protest in the 1960s and Richard Nixon’s vote share.

Shor was accused of “anti-Blackness” for seeming to suggest, via Wasow’s research, that violent protest is counterproductive. (Wasow is Black.) “At least some employees and clients of Civis Analytics complained that Shor’s tweet threatened their safety,”

Re:Resignation Letter by PunchTornado on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @03:01PM (#23850024)
the maga hat is the slogan that half the country voted for. it is not a misogynistic slur or a rebel flag. It encompasses a lot of ideas, mainly conservative. I don't know what a rebel flag is but I also wouldn't ban someone for it. this is the kind of tribalism that proves my point about cancel culture.
Re:Resignation Letter by istjohn on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:20PM (#23834810)
This is what-about-ism, not a substantive objection. One need not point out every obstacle to open debate in order to identify one important obstacle to open debate.
Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:29PM (#23834933)
It's not what–about–ism because they're not neutral agents. I'm not saying "they say they want intellectual curiosity, but what about unpaid interns" — I'm saying "they say they want intellectual curiosity, but they are the ones actively preventing that from happening".
Re:Resignation Letter by mancerayder on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:10PM (#23835509)
> neutral agents

Please explain?

Re:Resignation Letter by jimbokun on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:02PM (#23834546)
How do you know they support Harper’s not paying interns? Maybe they object to that, too.
Re:Resignation Letter by pas on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:29AM (#23858748)
"Cancel culture" doesn't mean no word from them for ever after. It means they get demoted, dismissed, let go, fired, etc. People are losing positions, jobs, power, control, income, reputation, titles and whatnot because of various reasons. Usually due to the pressure of a largely invisible mob.

For example the case of Stephen Hsu ( https://statenews.com/article/2020/06/michigan-state-geu-cal... ) ... I have no idea if he's right or not, but it's true he's bad at PR and science communication.

We know how regular big of a backstabbing parade the regular old natural science community is (string theory boo/yaay, money for colliders, SUSY, ITER/fusion vs something else). So it's not a surprise that social-adjacent science is even more hardcore in this regard, but this is likely too much and too fast. Yes, sure activism and change needs momentum, but people will be surprised when the hysteresis rears its head due to over-dampening.

But this has happened already many times (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sociobiology:_The... and here's an another example https://www.reddit.com/r/gwern/comments/hoeqyg/stereotype_ac... ) and likely will happen again. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Also, note, I'm not saying we shouldn't raise the bar for public (and semi-public) discourse. For example, as far as I know, adopting Codes of Conduct turned out to be quite okay, it laid the foundation for the way to deal with problems, gave a structure and rules to point at when someone crosses a line.

Re:Resignation Letter by deleuze on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:09PM (#23833645)
I'll start caring more about this "silencing" once the NYT editorial board starts including viewpoints that are actually silenced in our society. Until then, it's just whining about no longer being free from criticism.
Re:Resignation Letter by jimbokun on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:05PM (#23834591)
What viewpoints? Are we just supposed to guess, or automatically know which viewpoints you mean?
Re:Resignation Letter by orwin on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:06PM (#23835449)
Communism division of work, central planning for college-level education?

Worker cooperative can be more efficient than traditional company in some sectors, did you ever read any piece on that?

I mean, the two time i went in the US, i was in really liberal and even socialist environment, and very few seems to even have heard of worker cooperative, so it would be surprising, but HN always surprise me positively, so why not.

Re:Resignation Letter by jimbokun on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:11PM (#23835519)
This google search brings up several pieces from nytimes.com:

"worker cooperatives site:nytimes.com"

Re:Resignation Letter by specialist on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:48PM (#23834340)
"Cancel culture" has always existed. Socrates was literally canceled. And we're still talking about him.

Any one challenging power should probably play to win.

Edit: Spoiler for all the kids: Your generation didn't invite sex either.

Re:Resignation Letter by dcolkitt on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:10PM (#23835500)
There's a fantastic Slate Star Codex essay (which unfortunately I can't ironically link to, because that blog was cancelled by the New York Times) about the very point you raise.

Basically anytime someone famous and successful comes out against cancel culture, the standard rejoinder is it can't be so bad. Doesn't seem to have stopped your career, so why are you whining?

And the point is for every high-profile person criticizing cancel culture, there's a vast dark matter of nobodies who's lives and careers have been ruined. Nobody's reading there op-eds. Things are that bad for Bari Weiss, practically a household name, and not even that conservative relative to the median American. Now imagine being an entry-level associate reporter, and a self-identified Republican.

Re:Resignation Letter by dane-pgp on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:49PM (#23836039)
I'm reminded of this Russell Brand quote, which points out a similar Catch-22:

“When I was poor and complained about inequality they said I was bitter; now that I'm rich and I complain about inequality they say I'm a hypocrite. I'm beginning to think they just don't want to talk about inequality.”

Re:Resignation Letter by edanm on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:40PM (#23835940)
I love that article and am a huge fan of Slate Star Codex.

But to be clear - it wasn't "canceled" by the NYT, at least not in the way the term canceled is commonly used nowadays. He made the decision to take the blog offline because the NYT decided to dox him, but their purpose wasn't (as far as we know) for that to happen.

Re:Resignation Letter by joly_ on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @11:06PM (#23840764)
I think the article is "CAN THINGS BE BOTH POPULAR AND SILENCED?", archive link https://perma.cc/9XBH-VQT9
Re:Resignation Letter by wait_a_minute on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:07PM (#23833604)
There is a lot of space in-between complete censorship and freedom to be curious. If we were already at complete censorship, she would have been silenced already. Issuing a warning about the trend while we're on the ride towards censorship does not mean there is no trend. That is what she is doing here. She is raising the alarm.

If we had to wait to hear an alarm until silencing was the only possibility, there wouldn't be an alarm anymore.

Re:Resignation Letter by koheripbal on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:00PM (#23835350)
It seems like we're a lot further along the road than that - though perhaps not at the end of it - since this type of behavior is wide-spread.
Re:Resignation Letter by manfredo on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:56PM (#23834460)
I don't think this statement is primary about Weiss herself. Rather, less established writers are the ones that are most constrained by this environment.
Re:Resignation Letter by jimbokun on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:00PM (#23834511)
She is not making this plea for her own benefit, but for those who don’t have her same level of privilege.
Re:Resignation Letter by ReptileMan on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:00PM (#23833483)
Well the Tom Cotton op ed drama was literally this.
Re:Resignation Letter by jakelazaroff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:02PM (#23833523)
Tom Cotton is a sitting US Senator. Denying him op–ed space is in no way tantamount to "silencing" him.
Re:Resignation Letter by jeffbee on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:12PM (#23833684)
Also they didn't deny him anything. His idiotic vomit ran above the fold online. The Times admitted the opinion editor didn't even read the piece, they just ran it automatically out of deference to the senator.
Re:Resignation Letter by PhineasRex on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:37PM (#23834136)
Also worth noting that Bennett actually reached out to Cotton to write the piece
Re:Resignation Letter by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:47PM (#23835184)
And Bennett lost his position because of it.
Re:Resignation Letter by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:22PM (#23836506)
because of the article? Or because the entire process for handling it failed to meet NYT process standards for op-eds, and because Bennett himself was at best misleading and at worse lying about his own role and behavior in that process?
Re:Resignation Letter by ponker on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:37PM (#23836704)
There are 100 Senators, chosen by the same types of processes that put Donald Trump in the White House, why is being a Senator an automatic qualification for publishing in the NYT? Such a famous newspaper should be more exclusive than that.
Re:Resignation Letter by krrrh on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:32PM (#23834044)
Neither was publishing it an endorsement. Nor was it an endorsement when they published an editorial from an ISIS leader or going back some ways, Hitler. It’s important to know what politicians think.

He could have easily Had it published in the Federalist or Breitbart, but the average nytimes reader would never have had the opportunity to read it. Filter bubbles are a big problem, and getting Cotton on record in the paper of record is a valuable service.

Re:Resignation Letter by ReptileMan on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:35PM (#23834091)
The editor was fired
Re:Resignation Letter by nailer on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:10PM (#23837940)
> a resignation letter that will be shared far and wide and read by tens — if not hundreds — of thousands of people.

But not in the NY times, where she seems to have been illegally harassed. I'm pretty sure you understand this.