News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Tell a Real 1959 Gibson Les Paul Guitar From a Fake by libertine on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @07:19AM (#23830596)
>But IMO the biggest risk would be pieces that simply aren't original. There's quite a difference between an original burst, and some conversion burst. Both only one of them will yield extraordinary good ROI.

This is what I was going to ask you: what about the modifications?

One quite famous LP is the one from Jimmy Page, and I think that when he bought it either it came with a wider neck, or he changed it after getting it - one thing is sure, it wasn't the original neck. Plus he had many other mods. This would devalue a lot the guitar no?

If that happens, and it belonged to a super star, then it will get the value as an item from the super star, and not the item itself?

It's just odd the perceived value of collectibles - some people value the story behind items, others love the story of the item itself, others do it because they think it's a good investment. But when it comes to guitars, despite the history of Gibson, I'm pretty sure any '59 LP that reached 2020 must have a hell of a story to tell, with mods or no mods - unless it stood in a former studio player attic getting dust.

Re:How to Tell a Real 1959 Gibson Les Paul Guitar From a Fake by TrackerFF on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:32PM (#23836641)
Mods, on very old guitars, are almost unavoidable. That's why you see original parts going for thousands of dollars on Ebay etc.

Often times a pickups has been re-wound, pots have been swapped out, or what not. If you own a bone stock burst these days, you'll take it to luthiers that specialize on this kind of stuff - but back in the 70s, people didn't really give it much thought. Sure, they were valuable and collectible already back then, but not to the degree we see today - so people just modded / repaired them without much thought.

If some celeb has owned a guitar, then there's some inherent "bonus" on that - or at least, the value won't drop.

Now, if it's some regular Burst with no celeb history, that has new pickups and tuners - then that's probably going to take a good hit on the price.