Re:How can a disease with 1% mortality shut down the United ...
by nkurz on Monday July 13, 2020 @07:34AM
(#23819608)
I think your rule of thumb is correct, but I don't see how this implies your corollaries.
I think Corollary 1 assumes 100% infection at T_0, which is clearly not true. It's debatable what the correct curve would look like, but even in the worst do-nothing case I don't think it could possibly be this steep.
I don't understand the logic for Corollary 2. Even if we assume Corollary 1 (which I'd argue we shouldn't) why would uniformly doubling the average death rate reduce life expectancy by less than 1 month? I can't say for sure that it wouldn't, but I don't think the math is obvious. Could you flesh this out?
Your final sentence seems possible, depending on what "much more" means, but I'd like to see more proof. Adding $3T would be equivalent to doubling current US health care spending.
This rule lines up with age group and preexisting condition groups surprisingly well. It underestimates the death rate of older people, but is within a factor of two. It drastically over-estimates the death rate for children.
Corollary 1: If we do nothing, then hospitals and morgues will have to absorb a year worth of cases in about 2 months. Obviously, that’s a big problem.
Corollary 2: COVID will reduce life expectancies by much less than 6 months (actually, less than one month).
I suspect we could increase life expectancies in the US by much more than 6 months if we spent $3T on something other than the shutdown.