News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How can a disease with 1% mortality shut down the United ... by ggm on Sunday July 12, 2020 @11:20PM (#23816822)
A well written overview. I think what is sometimes not read well by 'why don't we..' type comments is that the non-deterministic quality of this is quite strong. We can say your predicted risk as an 80 yo is higher than an 8 yo but we can't say much else. So, the 1% mortality and how it distributes over a cohort by age, sex, (ok more men) co-morbidities (ok so overweight, type-2 and pre-diabetic) .. but then we can't really say "oh, you're the high risk for subsequent heart attack" or "yep: you'll face life crippling mental acuity hits" or "we have to amputate now"

Ask anyone if they will take 1 in 100 risk and they will casually say yes. Ask again, if you present them with real risks of life changing outcome at shorter odds, they may reflect.

I wouldn't stand in front of a 1-in-100 russian-roulette machine personally.

Re:How can a disease with 1% mortality shut down the United ... by ImaCake on Sunday July 12, 2020 @11:41PM (#23816947)
Agreed. The penalty associated with the risk is important too. Probability theory and statistics can get us the risk fairly easily. But putting a number on the penalty associated with failure is a different problem altogether. If getting sick meant a 1:10 chance of getting a really bad headache for a week, I would take that chance. But if it was a 1:1000 chance of death I would probably not take the chance.
Re:How can a disease with 1% mortality shut down the United ... by satherx on Monday July 13, 2020 @07:14AM (#23819480)
Sort of. It's important to point out that there are effects other than death. However, he's exaggerating like crazy, possibly by accident. Issue is that most of these complications happen to the same people. Young healthy people are nearly always fine. The virus is likely widespread in the military, and deaths/lasting impacts are minimal. Older, sicker, fatter people suffer an array of adverse consequences. In other words, the machine is highly biased depending on your circumstances. 1 in 100 is the worst case. Policy does not reflect this.