Re:Judgments of Henry David Thoreau (2015)
by controversy on Monday July 13, 2020 @12:12AM
(#23817094)
Thoreau's philosophy is an existential one. It is rooted in his ethos. As such, an ad hominem attack is a valid rebut to his system. The man extolled the virtues of living on one's own. On reducing to the essences life by means of a certain self-reliant stoicism. The man did not practice what he preached. Therefore his entire view is bollocks. It's not humble, it's narcissistic meanderings.
>The man did not practice what he preached
Maybe the point is that he would have liked to be able to put what he preached into practice, but wasn't. Maybe he couldn't even admit that to himself. Still, this longing might make his preachings resonate with others sharing that same desire. Just speculating here.
"Walden" is my favorite book to this day. If you try to analyze it, you might get lost in the weeds - I feel this is what happened with the author of that article here - there's a story in it: Don't focus on it, just let your mind wander and enjoy the pure, humble beauty laid bare throughout.