Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by VladRussian on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @01:25AM
(#2381469)
they didn't specify efficiency criteria.
Was it input solar energy to O2 output? to H2 output?
Was it input solar energy to electricity output - trees doesn't directly produce it, so what thermal efficiency coefficient they applied to calculate conversion, if it is the case?
...
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by johnny22 on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @12:00AM
(#2381298)
yes, if the plant sucks up too much power it might get too hot and lose too much of the often more scarce water.
or something like that anyways..
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by erikpukinskis on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @05:42AM
(#2382003)
Photosynthesis stops above a certain temperature due to quantum effects anyway, so there's a natural governor. And I assume plants' vascular system also does some cooling.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by thehotdon on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @01:49AM
(#2381548)
Engineering beats evolution, every time.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by dools on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @03:18AM
(#2381735)
Except for baby formula vs. breast feeding!
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by photophotoplasm on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @02:24AM
(#2381637)
Horses for courses, and all that.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by thehotdon on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @03:22AM
(#2381748)
Well, it's not just a difference in optimization goals; it's a difference in methodology.
Evolution optimizes by using heuristics and stochastic search--piling crap on top of crap, and obfuscating into oblivion.
Engineering optimizes by finding elegant mathematical solutions.
Sorry, getting off-topic. I guess I'm just bitter about not being a robot.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th...
by wladimir on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @03:58AM
(#2381803)
Evolution "optimizes" for a lot more constraints. It needs to be self-healing, and work for a long time without any outside maintenance and monitoring. It collects its own energy, and competes with (unpredictable) other organisms for nutrients and sunlight.
Good luck engineering a system like that. Elegant mathematical solutions are great, but only exist for limited, well-defined problems.
This doesn't surprise me, to be honest. Organisms have evolved to be fit enough to survive, and efficiency above a certain level might not affect an organisms fitness (or might even affect it negatively).