News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux kernel in-tree Rust support by tptacek on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:52PM (#23808352)
Respectfully, I feel like you're dancing around what Python has that Rust does not. It's not the "English-like syntax" (with its invisible syntax errors). It's that Python, like most modern languages, manages memory automatically, and Rust does not.

Rust doesn't for good reason! Not just zero-cost abstraction, but also, because for the applications it's designed for, it makes controlling memory much easier. There are ways in which writing a Rust program is probably easier than writing a Java program, in Rust's stomping grounds. It's just that it doesn't make things easier anywhere else.

Re:Linux kernel in-tree Rust support by paavohtl on Sunday July 12, 2020 @06:46AM (#23810413)
I don't disagree with your premise, but I disagree with the claim that Rust doesn't automatically manage memory. Rust absolutely does automatic memory management - that's one of the main motivations behind the ownership/lifetime system. For instance, when you create a vector, the standard library will automatically allocate, re-allocate, clone and/or deallocate the buffer when necessary.

What Rust doesn't do is to decide for you how to pass or share that memory between different parts of your program - it just provides you with options. One could argue that this should also be under the automatic memory management -umbrella, and I wouldn't necessarily disagree. But I don't think it's fair to say that Rust doesn't have automatic memory management.

I would also argue that for many simpler programs you can get away with basically paying no attention to memory management. If your program is a simple pipeline which reads some input, applies some processing and produces an output, your code might not look substantially different from any GC-based language. That doesn't mean Rust is an easy language or even a good idea to use for these kinds of programs, but I would argue that a developer proficient in both Rust and Python could write the same (simple, pipeline-like) program in either language with comparable time and effort.

Re:Linux kernel in-tree Rust support by nine_k on Sunday July 12, 2020 @09:01PM (#23816103)
Rust is a high enough level programming language to have a GC as a library. You can go with Rc and Arc all over the place, and have a Python-style ref-counting GC.

OTOH Go is a lower-level, less expressive language with a built-in GC memory management.

To me, the level of a language is the level of abstraction one can comfortably reach with the language, and not being close to the metal or not.