News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Announcing The Zig Software Foundation by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday July 11, 2020 @08:25PM (#23807479)
When I looked into starting an official non-profit around the Ardour (https://ardour.org/) project, I was a little disappointed to find out how much success made it much more complicated.

Founding a non-profit that deals with less than about US$10k a year is pretty easy, and seems worthwhile.

Go above that number (let alone up towards the levels where you can actually pay people to work full time on somethine), and you need a real board with real officers, and the board needs board insurance to imdemnify them against charges of financial malfeasance.

That was just the first complication I came across. After finding a couple more, I just gave up. I've love to have a "real" non-profit associated with Ardour, since that's entirely the way we conceive of the project, but the legal aspects to it when you're actually pulling in $100k a year or more just don't seem to justify the extra complications and requirements.

Re:Announcing The Zig Software Foundation by zachlatta on Saturday July 11, 2020 @11:27PM (#23808560)
You might be interested in Hack Club Bank (https://hackclub.com/bank/), which we built for our students at Hack Club after they kept having the same problem (but with smaller amounts of money).

Today there are hundreds of student orgs running on Hack Club Bank, a few larger orgs (one with a budget of ~$100K/year, one that just signed on with anticipated budget of $1M/year), and now Hack Club HQ itself runs on Hack Club Bank (our finances are also open source on it - https://bank.hackclub.com/hq/).

While the page on Hack Club Bank on our website is still focused on student-led hackathons, we've recently started support for nonprofits not led by students. Perhaps it might be a good fit for Ardour?

Re:Announcing The Zig Software Foundation by weinzierl on Sunday July 12, 2020 @05:49AM (#23810191)
Have you considered registering your foundation in another country? For example The Document Foundation - the non-profit organization behind Libre Office - is legally registered in Germany. Here is what Florian Effenberger the foundation's Executive Director had to say about the decision to register in Germany in an interview in 2011 (my translation):

"You have decided to establish the Document Foundation in Germany. Why should it become a foundation under German law?

A lot of people have asked whether it is necessary to establish the Document Foundation in Germany, because such a large amount of foundation capital is required here. In contrast, countries such as Great Britain or the United States offer similar legal constructs for a foundation without the requirement for a high foundation capital. The Steering Committee, after a thorough investigation, decided in a public telephone conference that the location of registration of the future foundation should ideally be Germany.

Germany is the best choice for the future foundation for several reasons: Not only do German foundations stand for security, stability, and trustworthiness, but Germany also has a large distribution of free and open source software. The roots of the product lie in Germany in the mid-1980s. In addition, Germany offers advantages in terms of taxes, tax deductibility for donors, as well as in terms of the foundation's activities, which are not restricted to a specific country from Germany.

Most importantly, many active members of the community who are willing to advance the Foundation are from Germany. Even if other countries would require fewer resources to set up the Foundation - if people who are willing to advance the Foundation are not on site, there would be higher costs for representatives and lawyers. Ultimately, however, a solid financial basis for the foundation would also be required in other countries."

Original source of the interview in German: https://ikhaya.ubuntuusers.de/2011/03/10/interview-mit-der-d...

Re:Announcing The Zig Software Foundation by beojan on Sunday July 12, 2020 @06:33AM (#23810363)
That interview sounds more like an argument not to register your non-profit in another country. The main argument given is "because LibreOffice is German, and many of the people who would be involved in setting it up are German".
Re:Announcing The Zig Software Foundation by weinzierl on Sunday July 12, 2020 @06:46AM (#23810411)
Yes, it's not a very compelling argument to register in Germany. I posted it more to point out that other countries are worth to consider and that running an open source non-profit in another country is more than a theoretical option. There advantages and disadvantages.