News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by rayiner on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:34PM (#23803956)
"You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain." Being in the good graces of the left isn't something you can count on. The fact that you got rich by making products people want and need and made peoples' live better is something that will be forgotten as soon as its politically convenient. Given which way the winds are blowing, "Big Tech" isn't making a mistake by trying to make some "right-leaning" friends.
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by klyrs on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:27PM (#23804425)
In the early days, they were altruistic and doing things to make people's lives easier. And then they turned into advertising company who sells personal info that was gathered under a pretense of good faith and respect of privacy. Disliking google isn't a political whim; google's practices are a capitalistic whim. When those practices went from "do no evil" to "profit however and don't look to closely at the ethics", that's when they lost the support of this "leftist".

"It's better to die on your feet, than live on your knees"

Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by due737ey on Sunday July 12, 2020 @08:47AM (#23810928)
Counter argument, it's wildly more important that people be able to monetize their data and most of the people against it are failing to appreciate how economically progressive data monetization is. People used to /pay/ for software, not just professional software but software in general. And when they didn't pay for that software it was often because there simply wasn't software of that kind for their use case. Being able to sell data is the primary reason consumers have access to the plethora of free and quality services that they have today. There has never been this many good free games, this much free music, nor any other similar quanitity of free and useful services like office software in history and a large amount of that is due to data monetization. It's nearly impossible for me to care about what the data privacy advocates have to say when the movement has historically handwaved away the social benefits of data monetization while clinging to dubious icons like Snowden and Manning.
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by harryh on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:43PM (#23805230)
who sells personal info that was gathered under a pretense of good faith

Google does not sell personal info to anyone.

Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by chrisco255 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:22PM (#23804381)
Gotta say, as a right leaning individual, they've got no support from me and I won't forget the censorship or selective targeting of conservatives. I'm as pro-capitalism as it gets but when I see freedom of speech threatened in the way that social media and big tech companies have been wont to do these days, I will not support their defense. They can be broken up just like Ma Bell and maybe we'll all be better off for it.
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by root_axis on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:39PM (#23804558)
I hear about the supposed selective targeting of conservatives all the time, but don't really see any evidence for it. Every well known conservative has a huge following on Twitter or YouTube. People sometimes point to Alex Jones as an example but he was clearly banned for smearing the parents of murdered Newtown children. I'm not saying that big tech doesn't lean left, but I don't see evidence that they target people just for being conservative.
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by zo1 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:37PM (#23805167)
The debate and acceptable forms of discussion are so far "left" these days that it's hard to see it and point to concrete examples of it.

E.g. look at /r/politics (or most popular default sub-reddits) on Reddit. It's ridiculously anti-conservative and anti-Trump, yet it's being portrayed as impartial and just "politics", when in fact it's a huge pro-left section of Reddit that is unfairly given front-page preference and backing. No right-leaning sub gets that, and in fact gets the opposite treatment such as /r/the_donald. One could say that the left-leaning individuals and groups are gaming the system and what we're seeing is a consequence of that.

Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by chrisco255 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:35PM (#23805147)
Yeah, they fact check or block obvious parody tweets that are pro-conservative like the "racist baby" parody tweet a few weeks ago. They arbitrarily inject warning labels on Trump tweets while ignoring anti-cop tweets calling for violence and destruction (not just this year, going back to 2016 even [1]).

The head of Twitter's Head of Site Integrity had this to say about red states:

“I’m just saying,” he tweeted in November 2016, “we fly over those states that voted for a racist tangerine for a reason.”

It doesn't just lean left. It actively hates, demeans and silences the right.

[1] https://www.newsmax.com/t/newsmax/article/737721?section=Hea...

Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by root_axis on Saturday July 11, 2020 @11:59PM (#23808688)
Trump is an extremely high profile rule breaker, and he has been given a lot of slack on twitter up until very recently. Making disparaging remarks about Trump voters is extremely unprofessional but it isn't evidence of selectively targeting conservatives on the platform. The idea that these companies "actively silence the right" is simply false; there is an endless sea of conservatives all over twitter and every other big platform. Ironically, on the platforms that conservatives control liberals aren't present or welcomed and they are openly ridiculed with extreme ferocity and have been for decades.
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by harryh on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:41PM (#23805216)
arbitrarily inject warning labels on Trump tweets while ignoring anti-cop tweets calling for violence and destruction

It's not arbitrary for twitter to impose a higher level of scrutiny on @realDonaldTrump (~83M followers) than on accounts from non-famous people with a very small number of followers.

It actively hates, demeans and silences the right.

  Trump: 83 million followers
  McConnell: 7.1 million
  Ted Cruz: 3.7 million
  Ben Shapiro: 2.8 million
  Tucker Carlson: 3.6 million
  @GOP: 2.4 million
This is what silencing looks like?
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by chrisco255 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @06:22PM (#23806652)
Excuse me, if I build an email newsletter list with 83 million subscribers there's no email fact checking injection ministry of truth at the IMAP layer of the protocol. If 83 million people choose to follow Trump, then Twitter really has no arbitrary say. They really are breaking their social contract and section 230 protection and they're becoming an editorial force with the power to shape public opinion as they exercise that. Just as it would be a step too far for SMS providers to inject their opinion into my private text messages, it is a step too far for Twitter to inject their opinion and arbitrarily target conservatives. They deserve all the hell they are going to get for this approach. I fully support breaking them up or suing them out of existence. Freedom of speech is too damn important for a handful of power-hungry silicon valley Inquisitors to control.
Re:Big Tech marshals a right-leaning army of allies for anti... by harryh on Saturday July 11, 2020 @06:36PM (#23806741)
if I build an email newsletter list with 83 million subscribers

Yes, if Trump builds his own newsletter he is free to do what he wants. But when he's posting on someone else's platform, he's subject to their rules. Welcome to how the world works!

They really are breaking...section 230 protection

This off repeated talking point is wrong as a matter of law. There's a reason that all kinds of people have made this claim but never actually initiated any legal proceedings. They know they don't have a legal leg to stand on.

You might want to read this explainer (from a conservative lawyer) explaining how this law actually works:

https://thedispatch.com/p/section-230-donald-trump-vs-twitte...

it would be a step too far for SMS providers to inject their opinion into my private text messages

Tweets aren't private communication. It's a broadcast medium subject to far different rules.

Freedom of speech is too damn important for a handful of power-hungry silicon valley Inquisitors to control.

Freedom of speech isn't under attack. Trump can say whatever he wants. He has one of the most powerful (figurative) megaphones in the world. A couple of small editorial comments on a single website, even a popular one, will not meaningfully reduce his (or anyone else's) ability to have their say.

You say that Twitter shouldn't be able to express its own editorial opinion. It's actually that point of view that attacks free speech.