Re:Blog Anonymously
by throwaway894345 on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:20PM
(#23795981)
I did. I said it technically depends on intent; however, in practice it's implausible that you weren't issuing a threat, and threats don't constitute free speech.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Blog Anonymously
by CathedralBorrow on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:25PM
(#23796030)
Ok I'm confused so can you please help me? My example was absolutely a "threat" in the sense that yes, I in that example would be serious about voicing my opinion and my intention to not voluntarily do business with that imaginary corporation while they employed that person. I would be "threatening" to do something which is entirely my freedom to do; to vote with my wallet.
But if I understand you correctly, this would be going outside my freedom of speech. Which implies that I do not have the choice to not do business with them. As in, I am obligated to purchase goods and services from them.
I am clearly misunderstanding this because that can't be right. Where did I go off track?
Re:Blog Anonymously
by throwaway894345 on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:32PM
(#23796109)
Of course you have the choice of whether or not to do business with them. Nevertheless, threats are not free speech.
Re:Blog Anonymously
by CathedralBorrow on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:35PM
(#23796132)
I'm still confused. I am completely free to choose whether or not to do business with them, but I am not allowed to tell them about my choice? Or am I not allowed to speak about it at all, regardless of who listens?
Re:Blog Anonymously
by throwaway894345 on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:53PM
(#23796343)
Issuing threats is not free speech. You're still free to choose with whom you do business. Terribly sorry, but I don't know how to make it simpler than that. Good luck in your pursuits.
Ah yes, and of course whether or not something is a threat depends on intent. And who could be a better judge of intent than ... throwaway894345. Who I'm sure has an incredibly nuanced way of determining intent that doesn't boil down to "SJWs have bad intent".