Re:Whose Land – Indigenous Nations of North America
by nepeckman on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:34PM
(#23795433)
The concepts of empathy and active listening are well defined. Calling those concepts "undefined, non-falsifiable, linguistic drivel" is completely unsubstantiated.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Whose Land – Indigenous Nations of North America
by s1artibartfast on Friday July 10, 2020 @06:04PM
(#23797091)
I think the problem is when the speaker gets to be the sole determinant of sufficient empathy and listening. It leaves no room for disagreement.
>If you truly empathize with me and understood my position, surely you would agree with me. If you disagree, then you have not listened with sufficient empathy.
Re:Whose Land – Indigenous Nations of North America
by pinkfoot on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:43PM
(#23795543)
Ok, let’s test that. So how do you decide if someone on a forum who you have never met has either:
1) listened with empathy, but still disagrees
2) ignored your argument, but replied with the same answer.
You cannot. So its just a linguistic device to bully other people in a conversation until they agree with you.
Re:Whose Land – Indigenous Nations of North America
by nepeckman on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:14PM
(#23795909)
It's harder to do over a text forum than in person, but it's not strictly impossible. The low hanging fruit is checking to see if a person is responding specifically to the arguments in your post, or just arguing against a strawman. You can take that a step further and try to determine if their response indicates they understood your argument. This is more error prone, but still a possible method of determining good faith.