For someone who values original ideas highly, this is a theft of the highest order. Wouldn't you agree?
I am glad you edited the article to explicitly give credit where it is due.
If "the idea" is so valuable, why doesn't it survive first contact with the customer? Why the need to pivot?
You seem to think that "the idea" is valuable, so feel free to point out where "the idea" was a crucial factor in success.
Since it's fair for you to respond with "okay, but you point out where execution mattered", I will.
Amazon, Google, Apple (wrt IPhone and IPad), IBM, Intel, Walmart.
In all of those cases, a competitor had "the same idea", and was first and better funded.
If you think that that's unfair, feel free to give us some examples of actionable "ideas" that biz people had first.
Afterall, if ideas were worthless, wouldn't having a biz co-founder with domain experience be worthless? Or, really, for hiring anyone to do anything? Experience is important because it helps us recognize what is a bad idea in the given field, allowing us to save precious time on execution.
Execution seems little more than the filtering of good ideas from bad ones that you didn't know were bad.
I think a major problem is that neither the biz nor the tech co-founders are the lynch pin, it's the correct combo of both + an amazing idea + that 'never give up' determination + timing.
I think there are a lot of people getting full of themselves, be it devs, biz people, or VCs. I think it would do us all well to realize that yes, we DO need each other.
Common philosophies I hear exposited in tech circles is, "Biz co-founders are a dime a dozen" and “Good ideas, in and of themselves, are worthless”. The argument being everyone on the planet is capable of formulating ideas, thus “good” ideas can be found in overwhelming abundance. One may hear this suggestion advanced amongst mostly “tech types”, such as programmers, developers, engineers, etc. Many of them believe value is derived from the conversion of an idea into a physical product. What group of people are typically required to convert the idea into a physical product? Why the programmers, developers, and engineers of course! In this type of climate, the notion that good ideas alone being worthless or that biz co-founders are worth less than their tech counterparts becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. This notion is advanced by none other than those that stand to gain the most from it: the programmers, developers, and engineers. Sorry guys. I don't buy it. Read more on this phenomenon here: http://thegeoffreyhull.com/post/3767537182.