Yeah, personally I think companies are better off using their best people in the hiring process; the old "A players hire A players" thing may or may not be true, but "B players hire C players" certainly is.
Yes, I remember reading someones arm chair theory that less intelligent people cannot gauge when they are in the presence of more intelligent people, but more intelligent people certainly know when they are surrounded by idiots. It was this persons add on to the Dunning-Kruger Effect and there may be something to it.
While saying that, just because one is an expert does not mean they are an expert at identifying other experts. It is it a skill set in it's own right.