Re:Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages
by sergeykish on Thursday July 09, 2020 @10:19AM
(#23780512)
Don't you afraid it would be like browser addons - developers selling users to spyware companies?
No, but that's probably because I've grown up in the wild west of the '90s, where apps lived or died on their reputation. Any betrayal of users' trust would result in immediate removal and condemnation.
Also, it's not like modern developers don't sell users down the river. In fact, that's one of the very few sustainable business models that the AppStore forces you to have.
The iPhone launched without the AppStore. The AppStore was not the cause of Apple's success, Usability and Power were - in the sense that it allowed users to do more things (access the web from anywhere) with less effort (no booting times or ceremony). It was the first mainstream device that made it really easy to browse the web; that is what made it successful.
The AppStore was just a play to entrench that initial success by coopting third-party developers and ensure they could only sharecrop on Apple's land: "If you do anything serious with our platform, we get 30%". That's it. Nothing to do with usability. The AppStore is actually a terrible model from a usability perspective, because it collapses discovery so much that it does not scale. "Tap and run" could have been implemented as a web protocol without a centralized UI and it would have worked just fine.
The same is true of Snap. Linux does not need a centralized store, from Canonical or anyone else; that's just a play for them to get a pound of flesh from third-party developers. It has been tried so many times before in the Linux world, and it has never succeeded. Even Nokia threw a lot of money at it, and failed.
What Linux really needs, as you say yourself, is to make it easy for developers to guarantee integrity of their solutions once they reach the user. That's why Snap is getting some traction: because it promises to move power from packagers to developers and to make it easier to guarantee that a program will Just Work, without having to deal with the packaging vagaries of this or that distribution or risking that an overzealous maintainer will "improve" your stuff with crippling patches.
If Canonical were sincere in their attempts to make Linux succeed, they would concentrate on that side of things and drop the AppStore shenanigans. But that's not what they are really after.