Re:It's Time to Fix HTTPS
by jodrellblank on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @06:04AM
(#2382037)
You would use it because it makes encrypted traffic on the network the norm. It makes it impossible to decipher your traffic without an active deliberate security attack instead of a passive sniffing session. It means when a traffic sniffer happens on your traffic they will get (plain text, encrypted data) and they won't know whether the encrypted data is 'good' or 'bad' and will have an easier time with the plain text - the "just have to run faster than the other guy" approach.
It's not encrypted if the keys aren't secure.
It filters out some kinds of common attacks, e.g. most (all?) uses of Firesheep session-cookie snooping at coffee shops. Of course, for us nerd types https isn't really necessary for that, because I can just websurf over an ssh -D proxy to a VPS, to encrypt the coffee-shop side of the link.
The fact is, even if the browser so much as displays "https" in the addressbar, you are giving the unknowlegable user a form of positive feedback when none whatsoever is warrented. Strong netagive feedback is a much more appropriate solution.