> Oh, China isn't so bad, yeah. But think about it: millions of Hong Kongers are still living there. Apparently, to them, the riots aren't so bad that they would leave for the mainland. Isn't that strange?
I have heard of many Hong Kongers who actually did leave for the mainland. Both during, and way before the protests. You never hear about them because they consider themselves Chinese, and so are indistinguishable from other Chinese.
But I don't have hard data for you, so take this as you will.
> As a German, I think it's funny you say that
All right. Encouraging critical thinking is a fair point. I encourage critical thinking.
I would assert that the example question I posted, is not one of educating critical thinking. It is of deliberately downplaying the value of the Chinese identity. I don't have a better source ready to prove this point, but if you are interested I could go look for some.
Furthermore, would you agree that the appropriateness of this question depends on the population? Would the Poles, French or the Jews of Israel appreciate such a question in their text books, and would they also agree that it's a normal question for the purpose of educating critical thinking?
> Do you think he has a chance of getting elected without universal suffrage?
I believe so.
The pro-democracy party won the recent district elections. This already shows that Beijing interferes way less with the democratic process in Hong Kong, than is popularly believed. Everybody was saying "Beijing would never allow it" and then it happened anyway.
I think people misread Beijing. In my opinion, they are not per se against democracy. They want to uphold national security, and they want to avoid damaging the interest of the rest of the country. If that's achieved, Hong Kongers can do all they want.
In the past, Beijing proposed a limited form of universal suffrage. People could choose from pre-screened candidates. Opponents said that this is fake universal suffrage, that all candidates are just puppets. From the perspective of Beijing, they want to make sure Hong Kong doesn't elect a secessionist.
Given that Hong Kong never had true universal suffrage anyway, not during British times nor after handover, I would say limited universal suffrage is still an improvement. And if Hong Kong shows that such a limited universal suffrage doesn't result in a bad outcome, I think it's likely that Beijing will relax the requirements even more in the future. It could be a viable path towards better and better universal suffrage.
I think that by misreading Beijing, and by insisting that they must be bad, Hong Kong wasted that chance. If Beijing really wants to clamp down on freedom they could have done it ages ago. Why would they even bother offering limited universal suffrage, if they could continue to govern Hong Kong the way the British did, namely with no universal suffrage at all?
I think that Beijing is far more willing to cooperate, to comprimise, than people give it credit for. That does not mean it is easy, but it is possible, given that one understands what Beijing's interests are, and what they will absolutely not compromise on.
> online signatures are too easy to fake
The petitions were offline.
> the majority did not sign in support. So you cannot claim that "the" people of Hong Kong agree with you, just that some do, which is less surprising
Agreed. But can't you apply this logic to the protest movements too? Hong Kong has 7.5 million people. The high estimation of 2 million people who joined the protests, did not constitute the majority either. So why paint the situation as "the Hong Kong people want democracy"?
What matters to me is that there are more signatures than people who joined the protests. It's true that their motivations may be different from mine. But still: they signed it.
> I don't think what I said above changed your mind about anything.
You did make me think deeper about various issues, for which I think you. And let's not forget that we already agree on a substantial number of points.
What about you though, have I been able to convince you of anything?
> I do have one last recommendation I hope you'll consider seriously: don't think you have to pick from a limited selection of sides. You can slice and dice them however you want.
Thanks. This is actually what I intend to do. In some pro-China circles I am actually considered anti-China. It got me banned from some forums.
> What if there are multiple movements going on at the same? Those who want freedom and democracy, those who hate mainlanders, those who want to secede, those who enjoy violence and any combination of those. Does it detract from the position of those who peacefully demonstrate for democracy in all of China if there are others who attack mainlanders for xenophobic reasons?
I agree with you. Hong Kong is not a monolith. It's normal for different people to have different opinions, and that there are multiple factions who want different things.
My point however is that all those other factions are taking a back seat. The rioting faction has been the most prominent one for a while now. They poison the well for everyone.
What's also weird is that none of the peaceful protesters condemned the violence. Peaceful Black Lives Matters protesters condemned rioters, so why did peaceful HK protesters not condemn rioters? More on this later.
What's more, for the most part, the mainstream media doesn't differentiate between those factions, nor do they condemn the rioters. The still paint the Hong Kong movement, on a whole, as that of "peaceful protesters want more freedom", ignoring the fact that the actual peaceful protesters have been taking a back seat for quite a while now. This is an inaccurate representation of reality.
All of the above, is what I mean by "hijacking".
I am not arguing that the true peaceful democracy protesters have no legitimacy. They have. Rioters do not detract from the position of true democracy protesters. But to pretend like only they exist, and that nothing else is going on, is disingenuous.
> Or maybe even the peaceful ones are criminals, guilty by association?
Some people (not me) say that peaceful protester are indeed complicit, simply for refusing to condemn the violence. However I've also heard that many peaceful protesters are afraid to speak up, for fear of retaliation from rioters.
> Do they? I haven't seen any Western mainstream media describe setting people on fire as "heroic".
That's not how it works. Western mainstream media portray rioters are heroic, by pretending that they do not exist, by hiding or downplaying their crimes. For example, the media edited the footage of that guy who was set on fire. They only show the footage up until right before the guy was set on fire, and then say that in this scene "pro-democracy and pro-Beijing people were having an argument".
Or more recently, a guy used his motorcycle to run over policemen. And yet, CNN downplayed that part and focused mostly on how scary the security law is, making it look like we should sympathize with that guy: https://twitter.com/cnni/status/1280071981447159808
> You said you understand the importance of democracy. Yet you seem to think that universal suffrage would be useless for Hong Kongers because they're already free. What then is the importance of democracy? Would it only be apparent once they're no longer free?
My point is not that democracy is useless because they are already free. My point is that, by not having an answer ready as to what they want to have improved in their lives, they are showing that they do not truly understand democracy.
If they don't truly understand democracy, then that means they are treating it as a panacea, a magic pill. How will treating democracy that way, result in good outcomes? Participating in democracy, and making it succeed, is hard work. It requires good-faith discussion, good-faith cooperation, making informed choices, voting based on good understanding of the situation.
Look at the middle-eastern countries, where democracy was forced upon a population with no prior experience or understanding of democracy: disastrous outcomes. A well-functioning democracy requires good understanding.
This does not delegitimize a true quest for democracy. But if they're just chasing democracy for the label, not knowing what they're chasing, then can we truly say that they are chasing democracy? Shouldn't they go back to school first and learn what democratic participation really means? What we have right now is not a proper, practical call for democracy, it's a rampage.
Also, since they already rank number 3 on the Freedom Index, are they trying to rank number 1... by overthrowing the government? Isn't that a very strange method?
> I also don't buy that they can't come up with anything concrete they'd change. It would probably be something different for every person you ask, but in my opinion the value of democracy lies in being able to discover the things that most people want to change.
It's true that discovering the things that most people want to change, is one benefit of democracy.
However, it's not a given. Look at the dysfunctional US democracy. Have they been able to find out what people want? Have they succeeded in improving the lives of their people?
Different people have different opinions => this is true. But this does not contradict my statement. One should be able to compile a table of "top 5 things people want changed, and % of population that supports that change".
I can list a couple of things that should be changed about Hong Kong. Sky-rocketing housing prices. Income inequality. Most of the rioters are from poor backgrounds. Strangely, protesters and rioters alike do not vocalize this.
My interpretation is that many people have bought into the delusion that everything that's wrong with Hong Kong is due to "lack of freedom". Which is strange, given that British-era Hong Kong, which was quite prosperous, also did not have universal suffrage.
> I didn't bother to watch the video, but I guess they thought their arguments were good. I guess you think your arguments are good. Have you ever convinced anyone? Isn't it strange?
I have not. I do not know whether you believe me, but here are my observations: pretty much everybody have already made up their mind, and are not interested in changing them.
Most westerners have a very casual understanding of the situation in Hong Kong. They get most of their information from the mainstream media. They think that's all there is to it. Their existing worldview was, "China bad and totalitarian", and the stories fit that worldview, so they accept it. Yet they are totally convinced that they are right.
When I show more contrary information, more contrary evidence, most people dismiss them out of hand. They either show no interest in seeing that evidence, or they immediately label them as fake.
You could argue that I too have a bias. And you would be right, because everybody has a bias. I assert that I am doing a best effort. And that to the best of my knowledge, what I am saying is the truth.
> Who else would be willing to help them? It's not like the People's "Liberation" Army is going to do their job. What's strange about trying to get as many powerful allies as possible?
Because those are not actually allies. Isn't it strange to ally with people who don't have your best interest at heart?
Hong Kong was taken from China by the Britain by violence. Under British colonial rule, Hong Kong never had democracy. And one of the reasons for Brexit was "let's kick out all those immigrants". And people seriously think that the British are going to save them?
Recently, Britain announced that they would allow Hong Kong BNO passport holders to gain citizenship. At the surface, this looks like they are trying to save the people of Hong Kong from tyranny. But upon closer examination, you see that only people born before 1997 would have a BNO passport. Most of the rioters, most of the anti-Beijing people, are born after 1997. This is nothing more than a meaningless show to score points, it does not actually help Hong Kong citizen.
As for the US.. well... Hong Kong protesters yell "police brutality", but more people have died during the first week of Black Lives Matter, than during the entire year of Hong Kong protests (this is actually an understatement: NOBODY died because of the HK police). On a whole, the Hong Kong police are actually very nice. Furthermore, the US deployed the army while China never did. And protesters think that the US is such a good place?
Also notice how the Hong Kong protesters never condemned police brutality during Black Lives Matter.
All this tells me that they are delusional. They are living in a fantasy, where the UK and US are utopia.
Your comment is kind of long and you probably already had dozens of conversations like this without hearing any good arguments (otherwise you'd have changed your mind already), but okay.
> The Hong Kong "protests" are not about freedom or democracy. That's just a pretext for xenophobia, hate against mainlanders, and secessionism. Neither are they "peaceful".
What if there are multiple movements going on at the same? Those who want freedom and democracy, those who hate mainlanders, those who want to secede, those who enjoy violence and any combination of those. Does it detract from the position of those who peacefully demonstrate for democracy in all of China if there are others who attack mainlanders for xenophobic reasons?
> Am I saying all Hong Kong protesters are rioters? No, many are indeed peaceful. What I have a problem with, is that the western mainstream media uncritically paints all Hong Kong rioters as heroes.
Do they? I haven't seen any Western mainstream media describe setting people on fire as "heroic".
> Despite the fact that the entire movement have been hijacked by criminals
So what is it? Are many protesters peaceful or has the entire movement been hijacked? Or maybe even the peaceful ones are criminals, guilty by association?
> What freedoms are they fighting for, that they don't already have? Let's say they get universal suffrage. What's the first concrete thing they want to change? Strangely, most aren't able to answer.
You said you understand the importance of democracy. Yet you seem to think that universal suffrage would be useless for Hong Kongers because they're already free. What then is the importance of democracy? Would it only be apparent once they're no longer free? I also don't buy that they can't come up with anything concrete they'd change. It would probably be something different for every person you ask, but in my opinion the value of democracy lies in being able to discover the things that most people want to change.
> But notice how the protesters are repeating a mindless mantra, and are unable to engage in a rational discussion with good arguments.
I didn't bother to watch the video, but I guess they thought their arguments were good. I guess you think your arguments are good. Have you ever convinced anyone? Isn't it strange?
> We've seen rioters waving the UK and US flags[4]. There were even open calls for Trump (of all people!) to "liberate" them. Isn't that a bit strange?
Who else would be willing to help them? It's not like the People's "Liberation" Army is going to do their job. What's strange about trying to get as many powerful allies as possible?
> Think about: if China is so bad, why do hundreds of millions of Chinese travel abroad every year, and why does nearly everybody return willingly? Heck, why do I still visit China?
Oh, China isn't so bad, yeah. But think about it: millions of Hong Kongers are still living there. Apparently, to them, the riots aren't so bad that they would leave for the mainland. Isn't that strange?
> Why do some people want to secede? One reason is because they've been fed a lie about China: that it's a backwards, dystopian hellhole.
And you've been fed a lie that Hong Kong is a violent, dystopian hellhole. Neither is true.
> Can you imagine a text book asking, "what were the benefits from Nazi Germany's holocaust"?
As a German, I think it's funny you say that, because my textbooks spent a lot of time talking about how bad the Nazis were, yet "what were the benefits of Nazi rule?" was a question asked by the students who were capable of enough critical thought to realize that Nazi supporters must have had reasons for their support. So "what were the benefits from Japanese invasion to China in WWII?" is an excellent question to ask considering the existence of collaborationist Chinese who supported the Japanese occupiers. Isn't that strange? It will forever seem strange unless you can understand how they benefitted.
> With "education" like this, is it any wonder that 80% of the rioters are teenagers?
Has education recently gotten worse, such that anyone who's not a teenager has been unaffected by it? I think a more likely explanation is that teenagers are more willing to revolt, and always have been.
> a guy in Hong Kong who wants to establish a new party that aims to be a middle ground group
Do you think he has a chance of getting elected without universal suffrage?
> Do the Hong Kong people agree with what I say here? Well, 3 million people signed a petition in SUPPORT of the national security law.
Meaning, that even if all of those signatures were made by one citizen of Hong Kong each (online signatures are too easy to fake) the majority did not sign in support. So you cannot claim that "the" people of Hong Kong agree with you, just that some do, which is less surprising. And don't forget that signing a petition doesn't mean they agree with you; they may have other reasons completely different from your own.
I don't think what I said above changed your mind about anything. I wrote it down mostly to clarify my own thoughts. I do have one last recommendation I hope you'll consider seriously: don't think you have to pick from a limited selection of sides. You can slice and dice them however you want. If there's a group whose aims you agree with but whose member's actions you don't like, you don't have to reject them all. Just look a little closer, remove the illusion that groups of people are monolithic entities acting with a single mind and assemble your own personal "side" from those parts of disparate groups that you can agree with.