News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t ask if artificial intelligence is good or fair, ask... by smt88 on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @12:53AM (#23767001)
> Then everyone is on even footing and you don’t get an abusive power imbalance.

This doesn't hold up to even a first test using a real-world example.

Consider making guns free. Even if everyone owned an identical gun with identical ammo (an asburdly artificial situation to begin with), not everyone can use a gun equally effectively.

Apply it now to crowds. If everyone owns the same gun, it takes far fewer people to band together and take physical control of a certain area. Even an individual with that same gun is effectively powerless again even two others: to kill one is to be certainly killed by the other.

Now swap the guns with fighter jets, zero-day exploits, bioweapons, fame, religious leadership, or any other form of power.

There is seemingly no scenario where your axiom seems to hold up, even in contrived circumstances.

Re:Don’t ask if artificial intelligence is good or fair, ask... by sigstoat on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @01:12AM (#23767070)
> Now swap the guns with...

muscles? upper body strength?

that free gun world sounds pretty good.

> Apply it now to crowds. If everyone owns the same gun, it takes far fewer people to band together and take physical control of a certain area.

that in no way follows.

Re:Don’t ask if artificial intelligence is good or fair, ask... by smt88 on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @02:43AM (#23767504)
> muscles? upper body strength?

The original post was about technology.

> that in no way follows.

Scenario A: No one has a weapon. Five people take control of a grocery store. How many people can take back the store without anyone dying? The answer might be as low as five. Certainly 10-15 people could do it.

Scenario B: Everyone has an identical gun. Five people take control of a grocery store. Same question.

The answer is that there is no number of people high enough to plausibly reduce the risk of death to zero. Someone with a gun can kill much faster and at greater distance.

Long story short: technology amplifies power. Sufficiently amplified power cannot be countered by equal power quickly enough to nullify the danger.