If someone is going to buy RIM and actually make something of it, it would have to be a company than Gets It. All the companies that Get It already seem to be facing the problem of having more success than they know what to do with. I don't see how acquiring RIM would solve any of their problems. But I'd love to hear about those problems if you can explain them.
I didn't feel that it made sense when RIM was committed to a Java-only vision, but now that they're whoring themselves out to anybody with an app platform and they hung their existing base of Java devs out to dry, it makes a lot more sense for them to jump in bed with Microsoft.
Based on what? I'd argue that they "got" enterprise, but are in the process of losing it. Are a very cruse measure, what about share price over time? Or units shipped? or...?
I was looking for a new phone for company use a few weeks ago. The BlackBerry Torch was the only one in the store that wasn't included free with any of their longer price plans. In fact, I would have had to pay hundreds of pounds to get one, in addition to the usual multi-year contract tie-in.
I laughed and bought a £15 Nokia and a pay-monthly plan with no tie-in, because as a business user, what matters most to me is having a separate number from my personal mobile and a separate allowance of minutes/texts/etc. that I can expense. Smart phones are all very nice, but if you have a laptop and mobile broadband with you most of the time on business trips anyway, also mostly just a cute gimmick. (That goes for the other mobile OSes as well, of course, but at least they don't insult me by asking me to pay more for their device than I can pay for a real computer. If I were willing to accept a two-year tie-in, I might have picked up an Android phone.)
It is an interesting point however because we may soon find that the writing is on the wall for RIM just like it was for Nokia. The question is, when will RIM's 'burning platform' moment be? And more importantly, if the bottom does fall out from their market share dramatically, where will they turn?
It might be that Microsoft is in no mood for an acquisition but RIM will be forced to make them an offer so good they can't refuse. The lean towards Android with their tablet offering is pretty interesting however so one might well wonder if they are actually starting the first step of hedging their bets in the other direction.
Interesting times ...
MS doesn't have the greatest track record with consumer products (Xbox not withstanding).
They OWN the enterprise. While I'm not sure the resulting products would be all that great (though everyone usually has great things to say about Windows 7 Mobile), it would be an easy sell to an enterprise.
Chinks in the apple/android armor:
1) Right now, enterprise applications have to go through the App Store (for both devices). It would be pretty powerful for enterprise to be able to push their own applications at their leisure to their phones
2) Existing tie-in to blackberry servers.
3) Android phones irritate me b/c you need a gmail address to even set it up. This is just an additional requirement for enterprise phones that shouldn't even be there.
4) Dev tools that people are familiar with. Objective C experience is harder to find that C#/.NET experience (Android is wash here with Java).
This isn't true for iOS.
On iOS, enterprise managed phones can absolutely push out their own apps and bypass the App Store:
http://www.apple.com/iphone/business/apps/in-house/resources...
And Android phones which aren't third-party app locked by the carriers (so no ATT phones) can already install any app the user wants. It doesn't look like enterprise phone management for Android can "push out an app" though.
This is a nice-to-have, and has IMO no bearing on the success of a platform. How many devs knew Obj-C well before the iPhone SDK came out? How many do now?
It's a bitter pill for developers to swallow, but the truth is that consumers drive platform adoption, and developers will learn whatever it takes to have a crack at the goldmine. Nokia went well out of its way to be dev-friendly, but couldn't produce a platform consumers wanted. Having a solid dev platform that's easy to use is good, but makes little difference when nobody's wielding your phone in the first place.
> "2) Existing tie-in to blackberry servers."
Doesn't last forever. The consumer preference for iOS and Android device is so strong that enterprises are starting to decouple themselves from BB enterprise servers. There's a difference between the bitchings of rank and file engineers and the CEO being unable to use the new fancy sexy device because IT doesn't support it. One gets more change than the other, sadly.
The tie-in to RIM's proprietary servers is a stopgap at best. Without it RIM would be sinking far more rapidly than they already are. It is an advantage that is shrinking and won't last for much longer.
but if Microsoft got really bold, they could merge with RIM, and have Nokia build the phones.
I know it sounds crazy, but hear me out - what if Microsoft bought RIM?
WP7 hasn't gained any traction, RIM seems lost in the weeds - the could merge the two entities and ring-fence the entire enterprise market. MS could convince enterprises to buy their phones/tablets/etc and achieve "full synergies" with their other enterprise applications.