News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by RegnisGnaw on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:31PM (#23762460)
That's exactly it. It reminds me of some aspects of China during The Great Leap Forward. The grain production quotas set by Mao was completely unrealistic. However if the local leader said it, they would be branded as "anti-revolutionary" and sent off to reeducation camps. So the local leader lied and said they achieved the quota and was praised by the party. This lead to other village leader saying they exceeded the quota (by more and more over time) so that they seem more revolutionary (pro-party).
Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by singron on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:57PM (#23762762)
Misreporting regional grain production caused the central government to export "excess" grain and led to domestic famine.

Replacing unnecessary uses of the word "slave" in corporate codebase probably has less dire consequences.

Our problems with race are systemic and deeply rooted in many aspects of our culture. There isn't going to be a small number if things that will fix racism. The journey of a thousand miles starts with one step. Unfortunately we also have a history of taking a few steps and declaring that we traveled a thousand miles, but I dont think the fix for that is to stand still.

Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by RegnisGnaw on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @03:02PM (#23762817)
Definitely less dire consequences. It was more of a comment on the later leaders. They wanted to appear more revolutionary (eg. pro-party) so they lied and exaggrated more and more about their production. Similar to how these companies are doing these superficial changes so they can appear to be more pro-BLM/Woke/anti-racist.
Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by axegon_ on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:29PM (#23762424)
The way I see it: free advertising. Nothing beats piggybacking on a hot topic by presenting a non-issue as an actual issue or a threat. Which is what that is, given that as far as cs is concerned, "master" and "slave" refer to concepts which have nothing in common with slavery, colonialism, racism, xenophobia, homophobia, bigotry or whatever other buzzword you may think of. What is a bit worrying is that those exact methods of promotion were used on several occasions in history, and neither of them produced a good result.
Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by brlewis on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:37PM (#23762520)
I'm not Black, but I don't think I need to be in order to answer your question.

I do my best software engineering when I'm undistracted. If I've recently been treated unfairly, that's a distraction. Anything that reminds me of the unfair incident is a distraction. If I were Black and experienced a racial incident where the words "master" or "slave" were involved, I can imagine those words reminding me of the incident and making it hard for me to work. Maybe I'd be able to compartmentalize by context; maybe I wouldn't.

I think this is analogous to bug chains leading to vulnerabilities. A bug by itself might not be a vulnerability, but it's worth fixing because it might be combined with other bugs in a way that's a vulnerability. Similarly, small issues can combine to become bigger issues.

Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by ogre_codes on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:48PM (#23762665)
Maybe you should read the perspective of why a black programmer finds it offensive and took action about it: https://www.cnet.com/news/twitter-engineers-replace-racially...

Also, this isn't a "New" issue/ BLM issue, while it's been sped up by BLM, companies have been moving this way for some time. Python dropped Master/ Slave 2 years ago, before it was trendy.

Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by entropea on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @03:20PM (#23762993)
I'm not against it if thats how I came off, I apologise if it sounded like that. I'm more against the corporate PR campaigns that drown out real material change for black individuals that those like Martin Luther King with the Poor People Campaign fought for. It happens over and over and I'm sick of seeing nothing actually change in society except for 15 minutes of corporate feel good time.

Those ideas, police & prison reform, housing reform, water & infrastructure, education, for black individuals is what I want to see. Systemic change that will actually have a real effect.

I was out for the past 3-4 weeks protesting against police brutality and BLM and it just seems like such a waste when syrup labels and github parent branches are the only change I really see occurring.

Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by ogre_codes on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @04:05PM (#23763394)
It is a small quality of life improvement for a small number of black people in the programming community. Nothing more, nothing less.

This isn't drowning out anything, nor does it alleviate the need for real change in the places where it's needed most.

If a company does the right thing for the wrong reasons, that doesn't make it wrong.

Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by ghastmaster on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:32PM (#23762470)
It aids in the defense during the next discrimination lawsuit, as it can no longer be used as evidence to support a plaintiff's complaint.

Edit:

> What does stuff like this actually do except give them some good PR?

Source linked in OP article:

> The request -- which has some suppliers furious and others busy re-labeling components -- came after an unidentified worker spotted a videotape machine carrying devices labeled "master" and "slave" and filed a discrimination complaint with the county's Office of Affirmative Action Compliance.

Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by nemacol on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:47PM (#23762637)
This seems like a legitimate question worth examining.

Are efforts to clean up terminology worthwhile? For who?

My 2c, based on my personal feelings and hope... no evidence. This is low hanging fruit. Get people involved and thinking about current issues. Their employees, customers, and stakeholders might grumble or question the value of this work, but it does start conversations (like this one) and that seems good.

We think and speak in the words we know and see. This individual change is not going to end racism across the world but I believe in aggregate, enough small changes over a long enough timeline, these things can matter.

I think instead of criticizing changes like this we should appreciate that they are doing something. I mean, it is capitalism and at the end of the day they are making a choice that this is a better 'look' than to do nothing. A choice more and more capitalist enterprises have made in recent months. To me, this speaks to the continued change in our culture.

On the other hand it does seem to bring about a strong reaction from some counter culture (? idk what to call it). Maybe this sort of thing makes folks dig in their heels more than it helps?

Idk. I think it helps. But maybe not today.

Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by GiorgioG on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:25PM (#23762388)
Does it really give them good PR though?
Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by treebornfrog on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:46PM (#23762633)
All PR is good PR.
Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by treebornfrog on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:46PM (#23762630)
Underrated comment.
Re:Red Hat to remove contentious terms like master and slave... by Clubber on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:27PM (#23762409)
I'm afraid the only thing that will come out of this is platitudes like this and no real change long term, at least until it all blows up again. Changing packaging is easy and gets you press. Search and replace is a little harder, but can be done with not many resources. Re-culturing a 100+ year old police departments independently while maintaining that police department's purpose is very hard and we have to do it for every bad one out there. Many cases need to be a complete ground-up effort.

I think people who can actually do the work and enact that change are hoping it will just blow over with the next news cycle, because it's hard.

I have hope though. I don't like living with our current justice system.