I'd argue the value was in it for media buyers. A lot of retargeted inventory is spent targeting people who are going to come back anyway. The agency then spins the numbers and presents it as if they were the only step in the process.
Some even take it a step further and conflate their retargeting with their prospecting numbers - there's a lot more uneducated advertisers out there for agencies to rip-off than educated ones.
Other than your standard ecommerce flows, online advertising is still an area of very murky attribution.
I am excluding the likes of companies like BlueKai (now Oracle) who facilitate trading the cookie to other companies for further targeting or completely different chain of ads based on a search click to another hotel chain
That said, all of this is getting killed by recent Safari and Chrome change of getting rid of all 3rd party cookies
Surrounded by content on advice "blue light"-- gets targeted for Blue-tooth lightbulb
> don’t need to keep seeing hotel offers for Florida
This is not for the lack of smartness in code - it is that the conversion funnel is so narrow that "saving that $30 per month, by not showing you the ad, on a $1m campaign" is not worth tracking and excluding. Although I do believe companies should take the extra effort to avoid the annoyance and be a good citizen - particularly once they have identified "the one real person who actually bought something" among 99 other bots/crawlers/untraceable entities. Not all ad companies appropriately value the real person and the annoyance caused to them. Some do.