News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brython – A Python 3 implementation for client-side web p... by wenc on Monday July 06, 2020 @10:54AM (#23748556)
Looks like the FAQ covers this question:

https://brython.info/static_doc/en/faq.html

Quote:

Q: why use the operator <= to build the tree of DOM elements? This is not pythonic!

A: Python has no built-in structure to manipulate trees, ie to add "child" or "sibling" nodes to a tree node. For these operations, functions can be used; the syntax proposed by Brython is to use operators: this is easier to type (no parenthesis) and more readable

To add a sibling node, the operator + is used.

To add a child, the operator <= was chosen for these reasons:

* it has the shape of a left arrow; note that Python function annotations use a new operator -> that was chosen for its arrow shape

* it looks like an augmented assignment because of the equal sign

* it can't be confused with "lesser or equal" because a line with document <= elt would be a no-op if it was "lesser or equal", which is always used in a condition or as the return value of a function

* we are so used to interpret the 2 signs < and = as "lesser or equal" that we forget that they are a convention for programming languages, to replace the real sign ≤

* in Python, <= is used as an operator for sets with a different meaning than "lesser or equal"

* the sign < is often used in computer science to mean something else than "lesser than": in Python and many other languages, << means left shift; in HTML tags are enclosed with < and >

* Python uses the same operator % for very different operations: modulo and string formatting

Re:Brython – A Python 3 implementation for client-side web p... by linkdd on Monday July 06, 2020 @01:04PM (#23749904)
I'll try to explain why I strongly disagree with the FAQ:

> this is easier to type (no parenthesis) and more readable

When 99% of the open-source codebase uses "<=" as lesser-than-equal, no it is not more readable to change that.

> It has the shape of a left arrow

Then, why not `child >> tree` ? or `tree << child`

> it looks like an augmented assignment because of the equal sign

No, it looks like a comparison. This is totally subjective.

> it can't be confused with "lesser or equal" because [...] would be a no-op

Wrong, the value of _ variable contains the result of the last expression. What value can i expect here?

> we are so used to interpret the 2 signs < and = as "lesser or equal" that we forget that they are a convention for programming languages

I agree, and trying to be subversive won't change that convention.

> in Python, <= is used as an operator for sets with a different meaning

The implementation is different, but the math are the same. The "<", "<=", "==", "!=", ">=", ">" operators are comparison operators.

"setA < setB" has the same meaning as "numberA < numberB", aka: a comparison between two object in an ordered space.

> the sign < is often used in computer science to mean something else than "lesser than", [...], << means left shift; in HTML tags are enclosed with < and >

You are talking about a character not an operator.

> Python uses the same operator % for very different operations: modulo and string formatting

This PEP ( https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0292/ ) tries to replace % as an operator, because it should not be used for string formatting.

Re:Brython – A Python 3 implementation for client-side web p... by corytheboyd on Monday July 06, 2020 @12:01PM (#23749261)
Not at all a Python user, but I don’t get how this is a valid argument at all:

> Python has no built-in structure to manipulate trees

What’s wrong with an API like appendChild etc? I know you’re just quoting the FAQ but if anyone has an answer I am legitimately curious. I have worked with Ruby for many years and loath cute DSLs but I always thought it was just the Ruby community that went overboard on that shit haha

Re:Brython – A Python 3 implementation for client-side web p... by dragonwriter on Monday July 06, 2020 @12:47PM (#23749732)
> What’s wrong with an API like appendChild etc?

Verbosity vs. fluency, given the application domain, I expect is the concern. I'd rather have fluent DSL separate from the basic language runtime, though, so that adopting it is a separate decision from using the runtime.

Re:Brython – A Python 3 implementation for client-side web p... by bruxis on Monday July 06, 2020 @03:16PM (#23751632)
+1, would have much rather seen a function-based interface for DOM manipulation than this monstrosity.
Re:Brython – A Python 3 implementation for client-side web p... by divbzero on Monday July 06, 2020 @06:55PM (#23753712)
I agree with GP on this.

Alternatives to <= that could be more Pythonic:

  document.append(node)

  node >> document
which parallel

  # list append
  list().append(item)

  # print to stream in Python 2
  print "example" >> sys.stderr