Re:Association of low to moderate alcohol drinking with bett...
by wcoenen on Monday July 06, 2020 @04:37AM
(#23745853)
I didn't really mean it as a "rebuttal", as the paper is careful about not claiming any causal link.
I meant it as a warning to the reader to be careful about drawing conclusions like that. To establish causation you'd need a study where alcohol consumption of the subjects is controlled by the experimenters. That would eliminate the effect of confounding factors that influence both alcohol consumption and cognitive function.
Not saying that’s that case here, but people like to casually throw around “correlation is not causation” as if pointing out the logical fallacy is itself a sufficient rebuttal.