News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by dx87 on Sunday July 05, 2020 @06:48PM (#23742788)
Pretty much. I've started seeing a lot of people saying "innocent until proven guilty only applies to courts" as an excuse for mob justice. It's mostly the same people who say "freedom of speech only applies to government censorship".
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by ntsplnkv2 on Sunday July 05, 2020 @09:39PM (#23743866)
You'll notice that this is people on both sides - only when it benefits them.

> It's mostly the same people who say "freedom of speech only applies to government censorship".

This is a different issue and is a lot trickier logically. But it essentially is true.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by tengbretson on Sunday July 05, 2020 @10:05PM (#23744007)
If you look up the word "constitution" in the dictionary you will find that it is taken to mean "that which we are made of." So if we as a society do not value freedom of speech, then by definition it is not in our constitution, regardless of what a piece of paper says.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by monocasa on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:04PM (#23742908)
So what, people don't get freedom of association unless they file for a court order?
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:09PM (#23742944)
People should absolutely be free to stop associating with others for bad reasons. That doesn't mean we can't encourage people not to, or talk about the badness of the reasons.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by bitwize on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:48PM (#23743238)
It used to be that people were taught: there is the law, and there is the moral principle underlying the law. So while freedom of speech is a thing protected by the Constitution, it exists outside the Constitution as a principle that instructs us that it is not legitimate to attempt to silence people for expressing an opinion you dislike, with whatever means you have at your disposal (shunning, character assassination, etc.), simply because you dislike it. You are still free to shun people with opinions you dislike, it just may not be the right thing to do.

Today, people are taught that laws are arbitrary and are made and used by the oppressor class to oppress the oppressed classes, and it is the moral mission of the oppressed classes to rise up and seize power so that the laws won't oppress then anymore. Which means that the moral principles are lost, and any weapon that finds its way in the hands of the immiserated proletariat can be legitimately used in the struggle to determine which class writes the laws.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by monocasa on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:19PM (#23743029)
But there's tons of reasons why someone might find their behavior abhorrent that don't and shouldn't pass the bar for illegality, and want to inform their employer that the employee's behavior reflects negatively enough on the employer that they would stop doing business with them. There's all sorts of acts that are never going to be proven guilty, because they're not illegal in the first place. Generally because making it illegal would conflict with the first amendment.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by 9HZZRfNlpR on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:56PM (#23743299)
That would only apply to America and other countries with weak workers rights where firing people is cheap PR.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:26PM (#23743084)
I disagree. I think there are very few actions so abhorrent that you should be fired for doing them in your personal life, and the vast majority of Twitter firings I've seen aren't over the line. Society isn't going to work under a standard where people who do bad things can't have jobs anymore.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by monocasa on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:34PM (#23743143)
> I disagree. I think there are very few actions so abhorrent that you should be fired for doing them in your personal life, and the vast majority of Twitter firings I've seen aren't over the line.

That's cool for you, but others obviously disagree with you.

> Society isn't going to work under a standard where people who do bad things can't have jobs anymore.

Or people will change their actions since they want to keep being members of society.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:39PM (#23743175)
I don't understand why you keep returning to people disagreeing with me as though it's a counterpoint. I know people disagree! That's why I'm posting; I hope to convince them that they're wrong.

Society is double not going to work under a standard where we don't consider bad people members of society anymore.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by dragonwriter on Sunday July 05, 2020 @10:26PM (#23744099)
> Society is double not going to work under a standard where we don't consider bad people members of society anymore.

Literally every society ever has worked under that rule, although the definition of people bad enough to qualify as excluded, and whether such exclusion was permanent or revocable, has varied.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by monocasa on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:51PM (#23743268)
> I don't understand why you keep returning to people disagreeing with me as though it's a counterpoint. I know people disagree!

Because you're trying to enforce your standard of conduct. That's cool that only technically illegal actions are the standard for you, but it's totally valid for that not to be other's standards.

> Society is double not going to work under a standard where we don't consider bad people members of society anymore.

That's an argument against freedom of association. Why do people get to be free from consequences of not to the point of being illegal actions?

Like that's the nonviolent method of enacting change. If you don't allow it you end up with far worse.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday July 05, 2020 @07:55PM (#23743294)
I'm not sure where I'm failing to communicate here. I'm not trying to enforce anything! As I mentioned earlier, I agree people have every right to shun others for any reason. I just hope to convince people that they shouldn't.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by salawat on Sunday July 05, 2020 @10:23PM (#23744077)
Forget it Zest. You're talking to a wall. Your message was quite clear and succinctly put.

Anyone here to engage in honest rhetorical exchange will have already gotten what they need. You're absolutely right. The true measure of a civilization takes into account the treatment of its least desirable, and given the practices the above poster endorses it is quite clear his concept of a society is one where it is acceptable to violently eject anyone who becomes undesirable at any time, with no consideration or room for forgiveness.

They are the one's demanding you acknowledge their right to engage in social warfare. You've clearly stated your position and rationale behind it. Just move on.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by monocasa on Monday July 06, 2020 @12:47AM (#23744792)
> I just hope to convince people that they shouldn't.

You haven't given any reasons for that other than a vague 'if we hold people accountable for their actions society will break down', when even the US court system doesn't take that view. The legal theory is very much that choices of association by members of our society are the controlling factor for the government not being able make (even abhorrent) political speech illegal.

If your views are so abhorrent that literally no one wants to deal with the fallout of being associated with you, you maybe should have reexamined your views before it got to that point.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by unethical_ban on Sunday July 05, 2020 @09:43PM (#23743886)
I mean, those are both really important to remember - while society needs to find its balance and have respectful, intelligent conversation about tough issues, there is no obligation to give clearly bad people the benefit of the doubt within the community, nor is there an obligation to give objectively horrible people a social media platform with which to spread hate.
Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by froasty on Sunday July 05, 2020 @11:13PM (#23744343)
It never ceases to flabbergast me that American civics has failed so utterly, for decades, to produce nominally functional adults that can somehow think that "clearly bad" and "objectively horrible" are Real Things That Exist and then say in the next breath, without a shred of self-awareness, things like True Objectivity Doesn't Exist or All Things Are Political.

Is everyone in America so ignorant that they don't know what happens when informal social standards become justifications for political suppression based on who the "public" and not the law deems to be "clearly bad" and "objectively horrible" people? You get lynchings and pogroms. You get informal show trials and massacres. You carve the stick that the next batch of self-righteous authoritarians stick up their ass to justify being inhuman, indecent, monsters.

I can already hear the response forming: "But we know that these people exist, are evil, and are harming people now! We have evidence!"

Yeah. That's what they always say.

I could list every group targeted throughout by self-righteous authoritarians through just Western history--Christians, Jews, Manicheans, heretics, lepers, Catholics, Protestants, witches, blacks, anarchists, communists, thugs, Muslims--and always find a justification that began with some variant of "But we have evidence that they were Clearly Bad People!"

All those other Devils were ridiculous, made-up nonsense. But not yours. Your Devil is real.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by AndrewUnmuted on Monday July 06, 2020 @02:34AM (#23745267)
I wish every one of my fellow Americans could read this comment. It actually is a fairly accurate portrait of the issue that most Americans seem to naively miss.

I have always suspected it has to do with how long we’ve maintained exorbitant privilege. We simply do not look outward, not nearly enough. Here we are marching about the racist police practices of our local cops while we routinely drone bomb innocents and starve children to death with not even a whimper from the same protesters. We fail to see how our treatment of other nations comes back to haunt us as our soldiers and companies bring the horrors of foreign wars back ro our local communities. Americans are so tired and overwhelmed with deceptive media that tells them nothing, that they can’t be bothered to learn the history and the media literacy to understand the division that separates the theater of the moving image from the reality of actual real life.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by unethical_ban on Monday July 06, 2020 @11:53AM (#23749177)
So, you're bitching about my perception of "clearly bad". And you are correct! I say "clearly bad" and also know that it is my perception. I think I am right, and people who think "all atheists/jews/muslims are bad" are wrong. I hope that my view is the zeitgeist, and theirs is not.

You take my position and move it forward ten slots toward authoritarianism, without any evidence or defense of your position.

You say that "as soon as the public has a collective moral standard to which they hold the community, you get lynchings". What the fuck? So, we should not have any collective moral standard? We should not have some shared sense of what is right and wrong?

My line, the line that keeps your nightmare from occurring, is very clear: We can have our shared sense of right and wrong, and yes, even shun or be angry at those who don't fit that standard - but those people are defended by the law, and the law grants equal protection to all. Vigilante justice against people is not permitted under the law, and violators will be prosecuted.

Before you tear up my analysis, please give an "affirmative" - that is, give a vision of society and government that fits your worldview without putting it in terms of what I have written.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by froasty on Monday July 06, 2020 @03:11PM (#23751568)
In the interest of good faith, here's my affirmative. In short, it can be found in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as adopted by the United Nations.^0

Articles in particular:

2. Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration, without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion (emphasis mine), national or social origin, property, birth or other status. Furthermore, no distinction shall be made on the basis of the political, jurisdictional or international status of the country or territory to which a person belongs, whether it be independent, trust, non-self-governing or under any other limitation of sovereignty.

10. Everyone is entitled in full equality to a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal, in the determination of his rights and obligations and of any criminal charge against him.

11. (1) Everyone charged with a penal offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law in a public trial at which he has had all the guarantees necessary for his defence. (2) No one shall be held guilty of any penal offence on account of any act or omission which did not constitute a penal offence, under national or international law, at the time when it was committed. Nor shall a heavier penalty be imposed than the one that was applicable at the time the penal offence was committed.

12. No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks.

18. Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance.

19. Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.

29. (2) In the exercise of his rights and freedoms, everyone shall be subject only to such limitations as are determined by law solely for the purpose of securing due recognition and respect for the rights and freedoms of others and of meeting the just requirements of morality, public order and the general welfare in a democratic society.

Whether this dialogue can progress further depends on whether we can agree that, despite having no official jurisdiction, a social media mob attacking an individual constitutes being charged with a criminal and penal offense worthy of legal protections as illuminated by the above. If you believe that it not being formal prosecution that such protections don't extend to the accused, then there's no point in progressing further and I reiterate my original post.

---

0 https://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by unethical_ban on Monday July 06, 2020 @04:08PM (#23752164)
I'll have to chew on it for a while. I would imagine, not being a scholar in it, that the UDHR applies more stringently to government action and use of force, rather than to a group of people without use of force or detainment.

Your definition of "mob", "attack" both would need examples. In a real world analogy: If someone on my street waves a Nazi flag and says God hates Fags, and our entire community were to shun him, refuse to interact with him, or at times, warn others of his beliefs - do you believe that is a violation of his fundamental human rights? That no person can be shunned or disliked for their beliefs?

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by froasty on Monday July 06, 2020 @05:02PM (#23752724)
> I'll have to chew on it for a while. I would imagine, not being a scholar in it, that the UDHR applies more stringently to government action and use of force, rather than to a group of people without use of force or detainment.

I want to be very clear that formal consideration of the UDHR by established authorities is not my contention. If you wanted solely an affirmative vision of an ideal society, then the UDHR is it.

> Your definition of "mob", "attack" both would need examples. In a real world analogy: If someone on my street waves a Nazi flag and says God hates Fags, and our entire community were to shun him, refuse to interact with him, or at times, warn others of his beliefs - do you believe that is a violation of his fundamental human rights? That no person can be shunned or disliked for their beliefs?

I'm going to elide some details from your hypothetical.

"If someone on my street [...] and [...], and our entire community were to shun him, refuse to interact with him, or at times, warn others of [...] - do you believe that is a violation of his fundamental human rights? That no person can be shunned or disliked for [...]?"

If the elided details merely included his race for example, would you consider that a violation of his fundamental human rights? If the elided details included his colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status, at what point does that become a violation of fundamental human rights? To me, the question boils down to this: is redlining a desirable and/or legal practice if the target is a law-abiding citizen in good standing, despite all other possible non-essential attributes?

From my perspective, the homophobic Nazi has done nothing unlawful or contrary to the UDHR, if we can agree that imminent harm is the baseline for where speech can infringe upon others' liberty. If we disagree that imminent harm is the baseline for acceptable speech, then we need to figure out the exact location of that disjuncture to continue.

As a further point, censorship, shunning, or suppression do not resolve the underlying processes that led to the emergence of the supposed undesirable element in the first place. If this element is a Nazi, it does not address why this person identifies as a Nazi, how he came to be radicalized as a Nazi, and what cultural or societal forces led to him falling through the cracks of the social contract to begin with. Similarly with racists, homophobes, antisemites, misogynists, and all other self-righteous authoritarians of whatever political identity.

Censorship, shunning, and suppression in fact lead to the opposite--it ignores their provenance, lets them grow in the dark, and tempers their own narratives of persecution and conspiracy. If the goal is a harmonious society predicated upon love, or at the very least brotherhood, this is not reached by excommunicating people from the very possibility of de-radicalization, de-militarization, and rapprochement.

To quote the Buddha:

"Hostilities aren’t stilled through hostility, regardless. Hostilities are stilled through non-hostility: this, an unending truth."

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by NoOneNew on Monday July 06, 2020 @06:49AM (#23746490)
Clearly bad people? Once YOU decided someone is bad, they are guilty by default of anything? This is how the courts worked back in the day in Germany with Jews. Jews were clearly untrustworthy to them. Same when Japan took over China. Chinese testimonies were worthless in court because they were clearly false to begin with.

The whole point to a court system is to remove prejudice of any form from the beginning. It's still run by humans, so it still nuttier than a squirrel turd, but at least there is an attempt. That's why when someone has multiple charges against them, they are not immediately guilty of all when they are guilty of one. You can't willy nilly say someone is guilty of everything due to one infraction.

But your backwards comment is the actual OPENING of the floodgates of hate, not the closing. The moment you decide to systematically silence people due to your will instead of through due process, you set up an elitist, rigged system. That's kind of the thing most people are trying to stop.

Re:Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2... by mistermann on Sunday July 05, 2020 @10:59PM (#23744265)
Who shall decide who are bad/horrible people? Such things seem far from clear to me, in no small part due to the massive number of variables involved, coupled with the unfortunate reality that people's perception of reality tends to be so fundamentally error-prone, and no error correcting mechanism seems to exist.