News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cornell Will Reveal Secret Academic Journal Pricing by patio11 on Sunday March 27, 2011 @12:51AM (#2374207)
Forgive me for being a cynic, but with tuition bills at about $40k per year, ground getting broken on $X0 ~ $Y00 million construction projects yearly, and endowments which rival hedge funds (Cornell's is relatively modest at a mere $4.3 billion dollars), I have to wonder why $4,000 a year for a journal sparks moral outrage and why the solution isn't "Alright, screw it, this is so easy we'll just do it ourselves."

It's like California getting worked up about the number of free donuts they give state employees. I mean, OK, I get it: high symbolism, makes for a good headline. But come on, one look at salaries, pensions, or health care shows where the actual problems are.

Similarly, if one wanted to look at the influence of money on the scientific community, it is highly nonobvious to me that academic journals are where the money is uniquely concentrating.

Re:Cornell Will Reveal Secret Academic Journal Pricing by anghyflawn on Sunday March 27, 2011 @07:37AM (#2374751)
OK, I'll bite. Assuming an average figure of $4,000 per journal per year, how much does will a university like Cornell spend per year on all journals? I work at a smallish European university, and even in my smallish field of the humanities we have access to about a hundred journals (give or take); I dread to think how many journals the university library subscribes to in total, plus dissertation databases such as ProQuest, non-academic periodicals archives, yadda yadda. For something like Cornell, I suspect the figure has to be much higher (more journals, more subscribers).

Plus, it's fine to think that Cornell can afford it; but can a second-rank public university? It probably doesn't, it has neither the money nor the bargaining power. Which means that its academics have limited access to advances in their fields. How can that be fine?

Re:Cornell Will Reveal Secret Academic Journal Pricing by justincormack on Sunday March 27, 2011 @01:07PM (#2375399)
It is not about second rank universities. It is about universities in the third world and people who cannot afford to go to universities at all, and it is about the support of universities for open access to learning.
Re:Cornell Will Reveal Secret Academic Journal Pricing by anghyflawn on Sunday March 27, 2011 @02:47PM (#2375617)
Certainly. Everything that applies to second-rank universities in this respect applies to even less advantaged institutions and scholars, magnified.
Re:Cornell Will Reveal Secret Academic Journal Pricing by lukeschlather on Sunday March 27, 2011 @11:04AM (#2375098)
>I have to wonder why $4,000 a year for a journal sparks moral outrage and why the solution isn't "Alright, screw it, this is so easy we'll just do it ourselves."

Cornell runs arXiv. You can't fight a group as entrenched and pernicious as academic journal publishers on a single front.