News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The science of mask-wearing hasn’t changed, so why have o... by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday July 04, 2020 @07:25AM (#23731575)
So you're Jeremy Howard? Hi. Someone on this thread recommended this article by yourself, on The Conversation, that I managed to miss a couple of months ago (I can't find again the post where the link to the article was given, apologies):

https://theconversation.com/masks-help-stop-the-spread-of-co...

From what I can see in the article, you were first convinced that masks should be worn after watching a youtube video. Then, having been convinced by the video you found more evidence to support your conviction.

I quote from the article:

The research that first convinced me was a laser light-scattering experiment. Researchers from the National Institutes of Health used lasers to illuminate and count how many droplets of saliva were flung into the air by a person talking with and without a face mask. The paper was only recently published officially, but I saw a YouTube video showing the experiment in early March. The results are shockingly obvious in the video.

I have to say, this rings all manner of alarm bells. For example, a video on youtube cannot be seen as evidence of anything, even if it's from the NIH; that video could at best be seen as evidence of a likely mechanism for the spread of the virus, but evidence of a mechanism that could produce an effect is not evidence that the mechanism produces that effect; etc. In short, all this is not "strong science", even if it led to strong convictions.

In any case, we all have to remember -data scientists first of all- that "data science" is not a "science" in the sense that e.g. epidemiology is a science and in a time of a public health crisis, the stage should be left clear for the relevant experts.

There are no comments on this comment yet.