Few people just opt in to having their rights violated
It's really only done because they know few people will voluntarily opt-in to something like tracking or profiling.
Given the usual "Your privacy is important to us" guff this makes their privacy terms look even shadier.
Most companies don't delete accounts when you request to delete account, they only disable your access to account. So, before cancelling I prefer to go into account, remove as much info as possible and change all other info before requesting to delete account.
AirBnb wouldn't even let me access my account until I accepted their new T&C and upon declining they just moved me to cancel account with no chance to make any changes to existing info.
But yeah, a lot of companies don't even do what the GDPR actually requires, let alone what people think it does.
"OK, send more data!"
As far as the pandemic goes, Airbnb has a lot less turnover than hotels and there are mandated days between guests to ensure the virus cannot live on any surfaces. That’s much safer than you’re going to get at a hotel with a lobby that has hundreds of guests coming in and out every day. Half the things you pay extra for at a hotel are now useless (gym, room service) whereas the benefits of an Airbnb like having a real kitchen and more private space are worth more now.
Man, this comment and some similar sibling comments betray this mentality where racism is the ultimate evil and, thus, anything done in the name of fighting racism is justified.
In particular, multiple people seem to think you're not allowed to criticise Airbnb's approach to handling private data _because Airbnb purportedly is using it to somehow fight discrimination_. Nevermind that:
* There's no transparency about how this 3rd party will use the data
* There's no data on how effective their approach will be.
* The default is opt-in, not opt-out.
* Airbnb has done ethically dubious things before.
Yet, according to some comments, if you don't let Airbnb use your data, you're supporting the racists/being tone deaf.
MIT just had to remove a major AI dataset that was used to teach hundreds of AIs. It had numerous examples of black people and monkeys labeled with the N-word and has trained systematic bias into our algorithms. This type of bias cannot be fought by hiding from the problem. What Airbnb is doing is courageous and you are free to opt-out if you don’t like it, but taking a big public stand against an organization for actually trying to improve things for minorities in 2020 is pretty tone deaf.
> but taking a big public stand against an organization for actually trying to improve things for minorities in 2020 is pretty tone deaf
From the email: "we’ll use first names and profile photos from hosts and guests to help us understand the perceived race someone might associate with them...We’ll use this information to help us understand when and where racial discrimination is happening on our platform."
So if I get rejected for trying to book a room, my brown face will be labeled "minority" and be used as a datapoint to help improve the company. I have every right to disagree with how Airbnb is going about this especially from a privacy perspective, and do so vocally.
Oh wow, first time a guy on the internet calls me a white dude. If you saw me in real life, or made any inferences based on my HN username, you would know better.
I apologize for being rude but to be honest it’s pretty frustrating that people would be so selfish as to make a big stink about it instead of just opting out. Do you know how many times Facebook or LinkedIn has opted me into research and sharing that I didn’t opt in to and no one even bats an eye most the time. Now that the research is about discrimination instead of advertising profits it’s some big invasion of privacy that we need to delete our accounts over. Not to mention that Facebook and LinkedIn typically don’t let you opt out at all.
I don’t think anyone would complain if it was implemented as an opt-in.
From the email: "We know your privacy is important"
Airbnb should prove it by making this opt-in instead of opt-out (and not hiding the choice with a bunch of boilerplate). I expect these dark patterns from a shadier website, not Airbnb.
Edit: If you go through "Account settings" you are only given a choice to "deactivate" your account. To actually remove your information, go here: https://www.airbnb.com/privacy/manage-your-data