News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by tedunangst on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:00PM (#2372700)
Twitter can't let you pay them. That would immediately cap the market value of each user and Twitter's target valuation per eyeball is way more than you'd likely be willing to pay.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by orijing on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:27PM (#2372765)
Interesting point. Let's see what that really means.

Twitter was on track for 200m users in 2011 [1]. Twitter was valued at 7.7b dollars a few weeks back [2]. That's about $38.5 per user. Surely fewer than half the users would pay for Twitter, which would mean that those paying must be worth at least 77 dollars. At a discount rate of 15%, each of those paying customers must yield 11.55 annually in free cash flow (i.e. after costs) to justify Twitter's valuation.

Of course, Twitter could always find ways to extract money from the non-payers, but yes, you bring up a great point: Is it reasonable to expect that half the users will pay about $12 bucks a year on top of his fractional costs to continue to use the service?

[1] http://www.tgdaily.com/software-brief/52284-twitter-on-pace-... [2] http://www.mediabistro.com/alltwitter/twitter-7-7-billion_b6...

Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by tedunangst on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:48PM (#2372823)
Cool, real numbers. :) I think monetizing by any means half of all users is very optimistic though. I have several accounts, long dormant, created as jokes. If that's typical (perhaps not), you'd have to divide by at least five or ten to get a real eyeball count.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by alexgartrell on Saturday March 26, 2011 @09:45PM (#2373843)
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by Lost_BiomedE on Sunday March 27, 2011 @01:26AM (#2374256)
You made my day. I have been utterly confused why I had not seen DCF analysis used much on HN, given the nature of the site.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by pyre on Saturday March 26, 2011 @05:46PM (#2373293)
That's based on the assumption that Twitter's market value should be equal to the amount of revenue that they pull in on a yearly basis. Somehow that doesn't seem right to me.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by orijing on Saturday March 26, 2011 @05:51PM (#2373305)
No, please read my comment again (I apologize if I were being unclear). I calculated how much free cash flow (a flow, which means it's not a stock) must be generated from each paying member (I assumed 50% paid) in order to justify its most recent valuation.

It certainly is not revenue ("i.e. after costs"), and is on a flow.

Believing that I said Rev(t) = Market Cap(t) is very wrong because I said Market Cap(t) * 0.15 = FCF.

Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by pyre on Saturday March 26, 2011 @06:16PM (#2373371)
Ah, I missed that. Though I was under the impression that revenue was cash flow, and that profits were 'after costs.' Maybe I'm misunderstanding the different between free cash flow and revenue.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by ZoFreX on Sunday March 27, 2011 @10:15AM (#2375003)
I didn't understand half of what you said... where would be good to start reading if I wanted to learn more of this stuff?
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by tptacek on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:20PM (#2372745)
Explain? I agree that the LTV of a Twitter user is higher than he thinks, but don't get the "capping" thing.

(I think Twitter "pro" accounts are a bad business move for other reasons, in the same sense as Google Search Appliances might be more trouble for G than they're worth).

Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by tedunangst on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:36PM (#2372790)
Fake numbers: Pro accounts will go for $10/month, but Twitter promised investors that free accounts are worth $20/month. This is going to lead to some awkward questions, like "How do we convert the pro users to free users?", or they'll be forced to revise down the expected value of a user.

There are a lot of companies with freemium models that work, but they mostly treat the free version as a loss leader. I don't think Twitter is valuing its free accounts in loss leader territory. That's my take, anyway.

Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by tptacek on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:40PM (#2372799)
If Pro users pay for quality of service, you can probably still sell ads to them, or sell their data to marketers; that's what I was thinking. I agree that Pro users won't be lucrative for Twitter.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by lloeki on Saturday March 26, 2011 @06:51PM (#2373455)
They might just be indirectly lucrative: pro users might just happen to be the ones contributing the most to the Twitter firehose, thereby generating traction for free users. In short, even if not lucrative, pro users may be a worthwhile investment.
Re:An Open Letter to Twitter: Let me pay for better service by donnyg107 on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:24PM (#2372757)
They'd still have ambiguity in ad sales revenue. And if this development is as profitable as this guy claims, I don't think twitter will be concerned about how accurately people can value their company. The price will tend toward actual worth and profit per share in the end anyway, so they'd probably prefer the profitable decision over the ambiguity of their target valuation. That's not to say I think it would be profitable, but if it is, they should definitely take the concretely profitable choice over the choice which allows investors to believe they might be a little more profitable than that.