News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by esperent on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:56AM (#23724552)
I do think that the area of knowledge management is very interesting and worthy of discussion. When it comes to tooling though, I've tried out a couple and I don't find anything superior to a folder full of markdown files + your favorite text editor (I use VSCode, but I don't think that's especially important).

Systems like Zettelkasten are interesting to read about, but again, everyone's brain is different and for me a bunch of folder categories and one misc/daily folder is just as good.

On a purely personal level, any tooling or system more complex than what I already use is unnecessary.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by lioeters on Friday July 03, 2020 @03:44PM (#23726871)
I'm in the same camp, all my notes are in Markdown files, organized as a tree of folders. Some folders are prefixed with YYYY or YYYY-MM, when needed.

My text editor, also VS Code, has extensions for Markdown live preview, to-do lists, and other conveniences - everything I need to manage the "knowledge database".

In the terminal, `find` and `grep` are perfect for searching notes. I have a few aliases defined for quickly adding new single-line notes, current date/time, paste a link and title, etc.

As a higher-level interface, I wrote a little React app / Node.js server that renders the Markdown files, with hot reload on changes. Not necessary, but I like having a "personal dashboard" of sorts, with calendar and whatever feature/widgets I want to add.

I also join the chorus, that we ought to welcome more exploration in the area of knowledge management. I love seeing new systems, open-source projects, applications, SaaS (though not as much) taking on this problem space.

Since the days of index cards, through Vannevar Bush's Memex, Ted Nelson's Xanadu, Englebart's mother of all demos, HyperCard.. In some ways I think the past decade took a step forward and a couple steps back. The personal computer, as an augmentation of the human intellect, has creative potential yet to be explored.

---

Edit: A recent one I found delightful is the Johnny Decimal System.

https://johnnydecimal.com/

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by jen729w on Saturday July 04, 2020 @03:58AM (#23730874)
Hey. Johnny-as-in-Decimal here. Thanks for the mention, I'm always happy to see someone making use of the system.

There's lots of work in progress on the site and the system, I just need to find more time. In the mean time, always happy to help. Contact details are on the site.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by lioeters on Sunday July 05, 2020 @08:02AM (#23738046)
Honored to meet you, Johnny!

I recently learned about the Johnny Decimal System, while doing some "research" following links on Zettelkasten and other systems.

I found your system brilliant, how simple you kept it, with consistent, easy-to-remember rules. I like that it has no dependencies on service/platform or language, it's generic in the best sense of the term.

As I was reading, I immediately started creating a folder structure, and took notes (in area "00 System" :).

Interestingly, I felt that the system builds on how people already keep folders and notes in ad-hoc categories - and giving it a few organizational concepts to standardize the structure. Like, I have a big nested folder of notes spanning years, and migrating them to a newly started decimal system, it's giving all notes a canonical place, with a defined schema/model/taxonomy.

As I wrote in the parent comment, I have a few aliases for shell commands, like find by file/folder name, grep to search notes, a shortcut to add a note. I'm now thinking of adapting them to the decimal system, so I can, for example, list all categories in an area, or add note to a category. I live in the terminal (and code editor), so having such shortcuts, usually of 1~3 characters, makes note-taking a natural, effortless step. I like that you have a page for such workflows from the terminal:

https://johnnydecimal.com/concepts/working-at-the-terminal/

For feedback, one thing comes to mind that could help beginners like me, would be examples on the site, like downloadable template(s) of common project organization. I had difficulty coming up with a sensible structure of categories - in fact, the "root" project where I'm moving my existing notes to, the foundation is still not stabilized, deciding where everything should go. It might help if there were some examples or ideas of categories, that could be copied and adapted.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by zikani_03 on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:11PM (#23728438)
I also rely on Markdown files and typically write very short content in each file, especially to help with my memory. I tried Google Keep, Evernote and at some point pain-stakingly migrated all the notes I had to Notion, but they are missing "something" I don't know yet so I regressed back to markdown files in a directory.

I created a tool to automatically structure files into a directory tree based on file dates because of this: github.com/zikani03/groupby

It is really great to see more attention given to this space. That and personal relationship management tools (e.g. Monica)

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by logicuce on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:22PM (#23729809)
This is exactly me!

I think the something missing in Notion is keyboard shortcuts and overall feeling that it does not feel fast enough. For example navigating to a page and then jumping between pages requires more steps than I am comfortable.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by input_sh on Saturday July 04, 2020 @02:07PM (#23733887)
Ctrl + P followed by first few letters of a page you're jumping to.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by lioeters on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:35PM (#23729261)
Nice! I could actually use something like this, for a subset of notes, or nested (and disorganized) folders of files, books, etc. Thanks for sharing.

https://github.com/zikani03/groupby

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by kuzimoto on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:46PM (#23729016)
Sounds like your writing style fits with how TiddlyWiki[0] works. I just started using it, but like it so far. Has a plug-in for editing in Markdown as well.

[0] https://tiddlywiki.com/

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by paulcarroty on Saturday July 04, 2020 @04:24AM (#23730974)
https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=patrickl...

Very easy to write notes in VSCode and render them by native render.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by m-p-3 on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:12PM (#23727090)
I do think that Markdown hits the sweet spot between complexity and ease of use for quickly writing notes.

I do use an app called Joplin[1] because it can sync to some cloud services with End-to-End Encryption directly within the app, has a mobile app available for Android and iOS and because it includes some other features I find useful when I want to polish my notes and include some diagrams using MermaidJS[2].

[1]: https://joplinapp.org/

[2]: https://mermaid-js.github.io/mermaid/#/examples

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by dheera on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:52PM (#23728706)
I usually just use straight up HTML.

<b> and <i> and the syntax of <table> are a lot easier for me to remember than some weird funky *'s and |'s. <img src=""> is also plain obvious, compared to some weird []!@() BS that I can never remember.

Top it all off with a custom CSS file and I'm done.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by mmsimanga on Saturday July 04, 2020 @05:13AM (#23731145)
I have just moved my personal website to WordPress because I got tired of fighting markdown and the SSG I was using. I share your sentiments on the syntax.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by helij on Saturday July 04, 2020 @07:47AM (#23731673)
You'll now be fighting a plethora of other things.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by Thorentis on Saturday July 04, 2020 @05:04AM (#23731112)
I started using Joplin but found myself trying to use it like a personal wiki, when it really isn't meant for that. I want a fast way to link my notes together. Zettlr looks like it has exactly that in mind, so I'll probbaly switch to Zettlr, and push for cloud sync/encryption to be added.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by kolias on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:10PM (#23725181)
> I do think that the area of knowledge management is very interesting and worthy of discussion. When it comes to tooling though, I've tried out a couple and I don't find anything superior to a folder full of markdown files + your favorite text editor (I use VSCode, but I don't think that's especially important).

I'd say the most valuable thing these tools provide is a way to link notes. That's the part that was missing from most of my attempts to build my own knowledge base, creating connections between the things I find and store in a way that's personal to how I think.

In the end, my ZK is nothing but a folder filled with md files that are all linked with each other in some way. It's synced to my phone and my tablets, so I always have them with me and I can always amend or work on them.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by bostonvaulter2 on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:16PM (#23728466)
How do you sync them to your phone?
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by _zg4q on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:49PM (#23729038)
I'm not the poster you're asking, but I've been using Syncthing [0] for anything I need to share with my phone (or any other device for that matter). Very simple and fast to get using.

[0] https://syncthing.net/

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by bostonvaulter2 on Saturday July 04, 2020 @05:51PM (#23735172)
That's on my list to checkout. Will have to get to that soon.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by esperent on Saturday July 04, 2020 @10:41AM (#23732525)
I don't especially feel the need to access them on my phone. I'm generally looking for ways to use my phone less, not more. When I'm out and about and need to save some info, I put it on Google keep then transfer whatever I've accumulated once a week or so.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by kiba on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:28AM (#23724828)
Systems like Zettelkasten are interesting to read about, but again, everyone's brain is different and for me a bunch of folder categories and one misc/daily folder is just as good.

I find that folders/tags inevitably just run into the issue of notes not fitting into any particular schema. So often time I just use the search function, or use a particular note that consist mostly of only organized links. This way I can have multiple schema of organization even if they overlap. Or rather, overlap is a good thing. It means you have multiple ways to find a given subject.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by esperent on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:23PM (#23725264)
The schemas are not that important though, I just use search 90% of the time anyway.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by endymi0n on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:58PM (#23725562)
Since realizing this about 5 years ago, I‘ve actually started optimizing for it. Whenever I hit cmd+s, I make sure to enter a search mindset and make the file name as keyword heavy and stemming friendly as possible. For smaller notes, I just have Sublime Text open with iCloud sync and operate freely with hundreds of tabs. Since then, any thought has never been more than a Spotlight search or a „find in files“ away.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by pqdbr on Friday July 03, 2020 @05:49PM (#23727943)
Same here. I've tried many different Markdown tools along the way. However, keeping everything in Sublime (files in Dropbox) is specially nice because I'm always one `cmd ~` away from having my notes, and one `CMD SHIFT F` from finding exactly what I need.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by emj on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:05PM (#23727020)
Stemming and keyword enrichment is something I've never seen done really good so I'm not sure you can build a tool that is good for it.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by andrei_says_ on Friday July 03, 2020 @06:17PM (#23728132)
What do you do about images in this setup?
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by type0 on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:16PM (#23727120)
But tags are very valuable when you can filter them, sometimes if you don't remember what to search for but know what it was tagged as you can find it fast. This only is an issue when you have a lot of notes otherwise I agree that search can be almost as good.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by SquishyPanda23 on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:26AM (#23724805)
One thing this ecosystem is missing is a measure of how effective people are after switching from one tool or another.

E.g. our company implemented the use of Zettelkasten in a randomized trial and engineering efficiency improved by x% in the experimental group compared with y% in the control group.

It seems like much of the ecosystem is like some areas of the Linux ecosystem, where the goal is more to focus on getting the tools and process just so than on the impact the tooling has on actual productivity.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by nl on Saturday July 04, 2020 @08:43AM (#23731868)
I can't imagine any really defensible way to measure this quantitatively.

Research outcomes are almost impossible to measure in the first place (see debates about citation metrics).

Qualitative research would be somewhat useful, but there's issues with that approach too.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by Kinrany on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:32PM (#23725349)
Re: research on engineering efficiency, there needs to be a baseline to compare with, and a way to make the studies reproducible.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by SquishyPanda23 on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:29PM (#23725804)
Yes, I agree. That's why my example was a randomized trial. But you could also compare with a baseline from results in the previous year or whatever.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by jpxw on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:45AM (#23724956)
How do you quantify “efficiency“?
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by SquishyPanda23 on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:26PM (#23725292)
However you like. Presumably people invest in these tools for some reason.

Maybe "developer ergonomics survey results" is one definition of the goal is just for people to feel more in command of their area of work.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by iamstupidsimple on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:38PM (#23726350)
<s>Lines of code / time</s>
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by vvillena on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:09PM (#23725653)
A Zettelkasten-style system is just a bunch of files in a single folder, with lots of links between them.

What makes these kinds of notes work is the purpose they are written for, and the links. Two people can have the exact same notes, but link and tag them completely differently, because each of them will have different goals and purposes.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by jldugger on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:06PM (#23726121)
So basically a personal Wiki for generation Z.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by jyounker on Friday July 03, 2020 @05:04PM (#23727628)
If you consider people born in 1927 (the inventor of the system) to be generation Z, then yes.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by madballster on Friday July 03, 2020 @06:39PM (#23728249)
Hegel (b. 1770) is purported to have used a version of Zettelkasten, as described by Hegel's sister: "He approached his reading as follows: Everything that seemed remarkable to him he wrote on a separate sheet of paper, which he identified at the top by a general label under which the particular content had to be subsumed. In the center of the upper edge he then wrote in large letters—not infrequently using Fraktur letters—the keyword of the article. These pages he ordered alphabetically ... and thus could by means of this simple method use his excerpts at any moment. "
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by vvillena on Saturday July 04, 2020 @04:19AM (#23730956)
In a tech sense, yes, it's nothing more than a wiki. The difference lies in the usage: wikis tend to organize their content using encyclopedic categories and hierarchies. A Zettelkasten is supposed to be much more goal-oriented, so that the right notes are found and interacted with depending on our work.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by nemetroid on Friday July 03, 2020 @03:04PM (#23726551)
Why is it for generation Z?
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by jldugger on Saturday July 04, 2020 @12:18AM (#23730081)
Cuz as a millenial I've been using tomboy / gnote as a personal wiki long before 'zettlekassen' showed up on HN, and I know a few others who run more online wikis.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by nemetroid on Sunday July 05, 2020 @02:29PM (#23740781)
...but zettelkasten is a concept that's hundreds of years old, so it seems strange to assign it to a young generation. I think it would be more accurate to say that personal wikis are the millenials' zettelkasten.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by jldugger on Sunday July 05, 2020 @05:33PM (#23742231)
I'm doing so because the trend of calling your notes by a old german word seems to be the new innovation here.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by ChuckMcM on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:07PM (#23727041)
Sounds like this system would work really well for you. All it adds to "a folder full of markdown files + text editor" are a way of putting identifiers into those notes that lets you link them.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by GhostVII on Saturday July 04, 2020 @08:23AM (#23731789)
I wrote a tool for myself that will just open up your default editor and create a new markdown file for every note you want to take, saving them in a git repo that you can sync to some remote. Has the simplicity of a directory full of markdown files, but also provided a system to tag the different notes, search for a particular note to view or modify, and view a subset of them in an HTML document. All of that can be done with different command line tools of course but it is nice to have it all bundled into a single program.
Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by maremp on Saturday July 04, 2020 @08:36AM (#23731833)
Do you have the tool somewhere to share?

I was looking into writing a simple tool, preferably a bash script I can use cross-platform, which creates a new markdown file with named with today’s date and opens it with $EDITOR.

This way I can also hook it to other tools, such as alfred pr albert.

Re:Zettlr – FOSS markdown editor for personal knowledge mana... by input_sh on Saturday July 04, 2020 @02:12PM (#23733916)
Not as simple as a bash script, but Obsidian (https://obsidian.md/) has this as a plugin.

Basically a button in the interface. You click on it and it creates a markdown file with today's date (example: YYYY-MM-DD). If one already exists, it just uses that one. You can also have a template that will be used when a new note is generated.