I can't believe I have to say this. This is obvious. Every coach knows this.
It's not an exclusive-OR problem.
Boxing for example (sport I did and helped coaching), unless you are top of your field, isn't recommended to do a lot of 'at home' training as you develop bad habits without supervision (dropping the defense, telegraphing your punch a bit) as you don't have the feedback. Thes mistakes have to be then 'corrected'
Boxing isn’t a good example because it’s a combat sport which means there is far more training than competing.
When I played football the ratio was close to 1:1 - games played to hours trained and something like 150-200:1 for when I was boxing.
What’s the likelihood that someone takes their same 10-hour drudgery cycle and doubles down on it by doing the exact same thing in their side project and why does that likelihood round to zero?
Side projects usually don't have the oversight where you learn and improve so much as when you work in a team. Is like learning to play football by yourself by kicking a ball against your house wall everyday, or play in a team with other players and a coach. You can kick the ball for 8 hours against the wall, but I guarantee it that 1 hour a week in a team setting you will improve much more.