Re:The epic roleplaying stunt Dau is now churning out epicly...
by tqi on Thursday July 02, 2020 @02:47PM
(#23716582)
But does the quality of the film matter? I don't think making great art justifies or excuses being a tyrannical/abusive artist, and feel that in general we should have consistent standards of acceptable behavior that is divorced from outputs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The epic roleplaying stunt Dau is now churning out epicly...
by dbspin on Thursday July 02, 2020 @06:11PM
(#23718701)
Of course it matters... If art has any utility at all, then its impact must be factored into utilitarian calculations about suffering / opportunity costs and so on.
Whether the suffering that's alleged to have taken place in its production was 'worthwhile' is an open and complex question, and its a perfectly valid moral position to believe that it was not. But to suggest that behaviour should be 'divorced from outputs' is not a logically consistent position.
Re:The epic roleplaying stunt Dau is now churning out epicly...
by TheNorthman on Thursday July 02, 2020 @06:28PM
(#23718852)
I think you are a bit quick to dismiss the entirety of deontology. Could you expand on what you mean when you say that deontological ethics ``is not a logically consistent position.''