Re:Systemd: Don’t fallback to Google NTP and DNS
by JdeBP on Thursday July 02, 2020 @07:57PM
(#23719465)
The fundamental flaw in your argument is that systemd-resolved is not a resolving proxy DNS server. Many other proxy DNS server softwares indeed are switchable between resolving and forwarding modes, some even doing both at once, but systemd-resolved only provides forwarding proxy DNS service. There is no resolving mode to default to.
Which is in fact the core of the problem. It's actually a fairly rare kind of proxy DNS server software, one for which there isn't really a sensible universal default for the unconfigured case.
Re:Systemd: Don’t fallback to Google NTP and DNS
by floatingatoll on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:06PM
(#23718083)
It’s not “stupid”, it’s reasoned out based on premises that you disagree with. The rest of your argument is weakened by that opening, even if it’s a point worth considering.
But I think hard failure is best approach in this case, because this behavior will also make it harder to troubleshoot issues, let say you are setting up a network and misconfigured your router that doesn't provide DNS now you will be puzzled why Internet works on some machines while it doesn't work on others.