Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act
by lazyasciiart on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:09PM
(#23709553)
So now, the terrorists and child molesters still use the bar, but they always go into the bathroom to talk. The owner suspects that they are talking about bad things in there, and installs surveillance cameras so that if the police ever need to know what's happening in there, they have access. Would you want a real life bar owner to record you on the toilet just so that one day the police can track some bad guys easily? Probably not. Do you think it's reasonable to expect privacy on the toilet even when you're in a bar owned by someone else? Yes, even if it might one day make law enforcement a little harder. And just like we think that people have a reasonable expectation of privacy when using places intended for that in the real world, we think they should also have it online.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act
by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Thursday July 02, 2020 @12:08AM
(#23709917)
What analogy does a bathroom have to a messenger app?
An open source messaging app that actually does end-to-end encryption regardless of whatever law? It might be less convenient to use, but people who feel they need to encrypt their stuff, will be able to do it anyway. So the end result will be just less privacy for people who "have nothing to hide".
Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act
by lazyasciiart on Thursday July 02, 2020 @10:40PM
(#23720561)
People use both of them when they want to do something in privacy, instead of sharing it with the whole world.
If you invent a message app that tells everyone it posts every message to a publicly visible website, then I'd agree that people using it aren't expecting privacy. I don't see it catching on though.