News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act by old-gregg on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:44PM (#23708205)
While I fully support strong privacy & encryption, there is absolutely no logic in this argument because it tries to build upon an unrelated hypothetical.

A stronger argument should have tried to explain how this violates the constitution:

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/03/earn-it-act-violates-c...

Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act by suizi on Saturday July 04, 2020 @09:42PM (#23736075)
It creates a committee which is extremely likely to pass policies which violate the Constitution. In fact, if there were really effective ways to reduce crime online which didn't violate it, they likely would have been passed twenty years ago without trying to piggyback on another bill.

I agree, the EFF should have elaborated more on concrete examples of how it violates the Constitution.

The potential space for bad policy is gargantuan and hard to explore without additional hints or context. Given that enumerated in rhetoric, tech company policy, recent events and the bill itself:

It may create potential for witch hunts. Think of some recent conspiracy theories here.

To censor speech which comes close to looking "suspicious" whomever is the one to define this. This is most likely the government.

It may push companies to use filters which over-censor speech and it may be impossible to get a remedy at the scale at which they operate.

Trolls could abuse mechanisms to silence opinions they disagree with. If a government decides to smear someone's reputation through a coordinated campaign, they could make the argument they are a danger to society and pressure platforms to silence them.

Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act by kulahan on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @07:27PM (#23775387)
You'll have to explain to me how it's an "unrelated hypothetical". Both situations:

* Indicate that you have a right * Which you probably don't have a pressing need for at the moment * But the lack of a need in the immediate future doesn't mean you won't ever have a need for it

The only real difference between the two, as far as I can tell, is the actual right you're not-using-but-still-protecting.

What am I missing?

Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act by lazyasciiart on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:58PM (#23709480)
The logic used here is argument by analogy. Talking about the constitution would be a different argument.
Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act by old-gregg on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @11:31PM (#23709684)
Analogy != "something different entirely". If we accept such weak criteria for acceptable arguments, one could argue for or against anything by picking a convenient "analogy".

Pointing out that a weakened encryption is analogous to getting a wiretapping order for everyone without a cause is a stronger argument.

Re:Oppose the Earn IT Act by lazyasciiart on Thursday July 02, 2020 @10:42PM (#23720573)
I believe the criticism you are attempting to make is that those are like apples and oranges. However, I completely disagree.