Re:Search is Google's castle, everything else is a moat.
by jbooth on Friday March 25, 2011 @03:18PM
(#2369884)
I dunno if I'd call search a natural monopoly at all -- Office has file formats and other forms of lock-in. Search just has a URL.
Re:Search is Google's castle, everything else is a moat.
by chris_j on Saturday March 26, 2011 @03:16AM
(#2371555)
I'm with you on that one. I've never understood it when people say that Google has a monopoly as powerful as Microsoft or Facebook. If a Facebook user finds a social network that's better than Facebook, tough luck. The value of Facebook is that their friends are on it so they can't switch to another social network. If a Windows user discovers an operating system that's better than Windows, tough luck if you rely on any applications that only run on Windows. If a Google user discovers a better search engine then switching is the easiest thing in the world. The main barriers to entry that exist around Google search are that search is really hard to do, not that Google have some kind of lock in that makes it hard to change search engines.
I really like joe_the_user's Mongol Hoard analogy. Google aren't scorching the earth or building a moat or otherwise erecting barriers to entry around search. With Android, for example, they are attempting to ensure that no fortifications can be built on the surrounding land. That's a very different thing.
Microsoft's biggest cash cow is Office but Office isn't enough of "natural monopoly" that Microsoft can sit easily enjoying the profits. Instead, one can find a long list of the underhanded tactics MS has used to preserve it's position over the years.
Search, on the other hand, currently does seem like a natural monopoly a la electric companies and phone companies. That is, Google doesn't have to destroy the competition but rather they are reasonably well protected by the immense cost and organizational challenge involved in a creating direct competitor.
I think it's correct that Google other efforts are protective but they're protective towards the situation of open competition in which Google arose - protective against pipe-squeezers and walled-garden cultivators.
Google is more like a "Mongol Hoard". Their defense isn't building moats and walls but clearing brush and obstacles so "everyone" has a open, level field - that Google just happens charge through more effectively than anyone else.