Agreed that for google.com search (and AdWords & GMail) there should be a few more procedures in place, but applying those procedures to every new small launch is a huge blocker.
Again, Yahoo had this too, and then some. I remember once having a launch shut down three times -- by PR, Paranoids, and Legal.
Actually, what I wish more companies did was have annual "feature killing" and "procedure killing" parties, where you reevaluate everything the company does, and if its cost is greater than its benefit, get rid of it. So "we'll institute a procedure so this never happens again" becomes "we'll try to institute a procedure so this doesn't happen again in the next year, see what its impact is on productivity, and if it saves more than it costs, we keep it."
ANY time there's an accretive process, there needs to be a corresponding ablative process to go with it. Especially around rules, laws, etc.
Otherwise, organizations calcify rapidly.
Isn't that the point? They are there to maintain a larger point of view from individual developers. Giving every person with their own agenda launch authority is disastrous (in a large organization): Of course my project is important. My project doesn't need review, I wrote it.