Re:Thousands of U.S. judges who broke laws, oaths remained o...
by thex10 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @07:21PM
(#23695954)
> [...] imagine a case where there is absolutely compelling grounds for thinking that [...]
FYI the system which we are discussing does not entertain such a notion. Or else we wouldn't need or bother with juries, whose main job is to deliberate and argue over whether presented evidence is compelling enough to remove any possibility of doubt.
> So given the legal "room" to hand down a harsher-than-would-otherwise-be sentence for some separate offense, that doesn't strike me as totally inappropriate or out of line with our expectations about what judges should do
I... _wildly_ disagree with this.
Not that my disagreement here should matter much – surely the justice/legal system has its own expectations here, that would trump yours or mine?
FYI the system which we are discussing does not entertain such a notion. Or else we wouldn't need or bother with juries, whose main job is to deliberate and argue over whether presented evidence is compelling enough to remove any possibility of doubt.
> So given the legal "room" to hand down a harsher-than-would-otherwise-be sentence for some separate offense, that doesn't strike me as totally inappropriate or out of line with our expectations about what judges should do
I... _wildly_ disagree with this. Not that my disagreement here should matter much – surely the justice/legal system has its own expectations here, that would trump yours or mine?