The answer to this question doesn't really matter for that reason.
The vast majority of kids are in foster care because otherwise their parents would be "unreachable" for social workers, for various reasons, like refusing psych treatment for their kid that the school insists on, like autism treatment for "difficult" children, sometimes just because they can't because treatment can only happen during working hours, but the parents need to work. Meaning they are hostages to "force change". That group is huge. Next largest group are kids suspected of a crime. Keep in mind that the way our law works kids don't have any legal rights. They may be convicted of a crime but for kids there is no difference between suspected and convicted.
The thing is, with just kids in youth services that really NEED to be somewhere the current system cannot possibly survive.
If my parents had both died during my childhood we knew we'd live with our cousins Catherine and Victoria. If somehow we didn't come with a pile of money (from insurance paying out or other mechanisms that fire when two child-rearing age people suddenly die) things would have been very tight for my Uncle and his wife but we'd have family.
And let's not forget that there really aren't that many effective ways to reduce recidivism, so this ought to be worth a lot to society.
Generally carrots work a LOT better than sticks.
Such programs exist, in a limited way: https://www.npr.org/2018/12/06/663516573/programs-help-incar...
You might say "well to protect kids". Except, there's a massive body of research proving that they make things worse, certainly on average:
https://sci-hub.se/10.1257/aer.97.5.1583
Massive negative effects, from reading scores, to later earnings, to subjective happiness (yes, really, kids report more happiness while being abused than in youth services), to later crimes.
So no youth protection is better for everyone. This is obvious in the case of scandals and the many "accidents". But it is true in general. And it is true for everyone. No child protection is better for the kid, for families (obviously I guess), and due to the increase in crime if we destroyed youth protection causes, it is better for society itself. If you start checking, you will find that youth protection is involved in the raising of many of the worst criminals we've ever known.
Even child psychiatry and "special needs schools" ... well. Comparing symptoms upon entry and symptoms upon exit paints a very clear picture that really questions why they're allowed to exist.
https://sci-hub.se/https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007...
And then of course there's the many scandals that these people keep and keep and keep producing. Abuse within foster families is higher than in families in youth protection services. In institutions it is a lot higher.
So they don't protect kids.
And crimes are astronomically higher in both foster care and institutional care (and youth psychiatry).
So they don't protect society against those kids either.