Also, speaking as somebody who recently voted for local judges and prosecutors, I got to choose a prosecutor who won't take police-union money and a judge who thinks they can do better than the possibly-corrupt incumbent. I wouldn't give up this vote just for some imagined peace in the political process.
You see this seems massively inappropriate in the first place. Take that money for what? A prosecutor shouldn't take any money from anyone, in any circumstance, apart from their salary. They shouldn't even be talking to a political organisation like a union.
Both things seem like grounds for automatic dismissal for a prosecutor. Why are you having to check for it as a voter?
Yes, it's stressful being a vigilant voter. But what's the alternative? Not caring?
Instead we have a situation where, as the article points out, corruption is swept away where people get to walk away with a cozy retirement and say 'well gosh I regret my mistakes' as if that fixes the fact that they ruined someone's life over a failure to pay traffic fees.
That's the example of the revolving door and people who abuse it get away scott-free.
Not electing prosecutors and judges.
That's where this thread started.
Its kind of like how two competent people can implement a POSIX compliant operating system in different ways (microkernel or monolithic, emacs vs vi, systemd vs sysvinit).
Their qualifications, history, and biases. I mean it isn't like most judges are getting the position without having a law degree, so the majority of them are in fact qualified for the position. So how else do you fill a public position when you have multiple qualified people and a single position. The argument for election is so to reduce nepotism and cronyism.
They should leave them at home if they're a freaking judge!!
You're telling me that Gorsuch doesn't have biases? RBG? Kavanaugh? Roberts? Sotomayor?
All these people interpret the same laws in different ways. If that isn't called bias than I don't know what is. The issue is that there is no objective truth, at least one which can be known. All laws are subject to interpretation. In fact, that is literally why we have judges and juries in the first place. To scrutinize and check interpretation of laws.
Are you telling me there's an objective truth to what "Freedom of Speech" means? What "the right to bare arms" is?
If there are major questions of interpretation they leave it to the legislature to clarify.
I'm not sure why you would expect judges to be a special class of people that are void of opinions.
I'm pretty sure it is... why would you elect a judge? They're not supposed to apply any opinion just interpret the law technically. What are people voting for them based on? Their political affiliation? That's absolutely bonkers.