Re:Show HN: Funny, Human-Memorable SHA-256 Fingerprints
by londons_explore on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:03PM
(#23692194)
Having generated user passwords with dictionary[random()] a few times, I can tell you you will get angry users moaning about the fact you defaulted their password to "You Fat Pig", or "Dumb Looks".
A surprising percentage of random combinations of innocuous words can be found offensive by someone, and automatic filtering is pretty much impossible.
Re:Show HN: Funny, Human-Memorable SHA-256 Fingerprints
by paledot on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:10PM
(#23696309)
At work I briefly experimented with naming releases deterministically based on the git hash and a common words list. I generated 20 random 3-word phrases as a quick proof of concept, and 3 of the 20 were easily construed as sexually suggestive.
I filed a bug report with the English language, but it was rejected.
Re:Show HN: Funny, Human-Memorable SHA-256 Fingerprints
by eneuman on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:11PM
(#23692291)
That's pretty funny, and you're right. I'm just avoiding the very obvious ones, but there will always be more!
Re:Show HN: Funny, Human-Memorable SHA-256 Fingerprints
by trefil on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @01:13PM
(#23692324)
Maybe you should consider telling your users not to get offended by machine generated semi-random strings of words.
Re:Show HN: Funny, Human-Memorable SHA-256 Fingerprints
by preinheimer on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @02:01PM
(#23692876)
For a password generator we ended up going with something like three pieces: predefined word list, list of all the colours CSS supports, two digit number. I originally tried to use more of our own word list but the possibly offensive combinations drove us away.
We're not making passwords anymore (yay!) but use it for like coupon code generation.
Re:Show HN: Funny, Human-Memorable SHA-256 Fingerprints
by dependenttypes on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:21AM
(#23698725)
> the PGP word list covers just 2 bits per word
huh? no, it covers 8 bits per word, just a bit less than yours (6 vs 8 words per 64 bits)
I appreciate the reference to the PGP word list, I didn't know about it.
One thing MadHash adds is a bit of structure in the form of <adjective> <noun> <adverb> <verb> <adjective> <noun> which should help make the phrases more memorable.
Also, each sentence covers 64 bits, whereas the PGP word list covers just 2 bits per word.