What's so silly about that?
For juicier targets, something more sophisticated is necessary. Captchas are one answer.
> For some reason this article has hit the front page of Hacker News and is getting quite a lot of traffic. I should mention that yes, I acknowledge CAPTCHAs are of course sometimes unavoidable. That doesn’t mean, however, that we should ever feel good about using them, nor should we fool ourselves that users don’t mind them.
Which was my point. When spam is a serious issue then captchas are unavoidable 99% of the time.
Spammers are probably not targeting your website in particular, rather the software your forum is run on. If you add atypical anti-spam measures you'll separate yourself from others using the same platform, defeating the typical phpbb or vbulletin bot which probably accounts for most of your spam.
I honestly believe that CAPTCHA's are one of the most evil things on the internet and that there are many valid and better ways to avoid spam.
BTW im not just some random guy with an axe to grind over this, I wrote http://www.wausita.com/captcha/ as an example of how trivial 90% of the CAPTCHA's on the web are trivial to decode.
So yes, who would spam animoto? But you know what, now their spam filter is good enough, their user registration has been increased. Better more "foolproof" techniques will always be needed, and directed attacks are hard to prevent, but getting to a good enough point is great as well.
And the problem you face may be a smaller percentage of sites than animoto, who do need captcha especially if you are the target of a directed attack.
We operate a forum with 250k members and ~800k posts per month, a new registration every minute and we get so many spam bots even with captcha (mechanical turk etc) and without captcha it's unworkable. Captcha is a necessary evil, but it does help.
This seems to be coming from someone dealing with a site where spam wouldn't be that much of a problem, who would sign up to animoto to spam? Very silly post.