Re:Android Honeycomb not immediately open sourced
by jonhohle on Friday March 25, 2011 @11:55AM
(#2369012)
> tightly controlled and still been somewhat 'open' (see Windows vs Mac).
Huge chunks of OS X are open source. It's not necessarily equivalent to throw it into the same box as Windows (there are no "open" forks of a Windows based OS, but there are of Darwin, and FreeBSD has benefited from Apple as well.)
Re:Android Honeycomb not immediately open sourced
by davidw on Friday March 25, 2011 @12:10PM
(#2369072)
I meant more in the sense of how tightly controlled Mac has always been, whereas Windows ran on a variety of platforms.
Re:Android Honeycomb not immediately open sourced
by seabee on Friday March 25, 2011 @02:38PM
(#2369720)
Isn't Darwin open source in the same way Android is? As in, the development process can only be seen by those in the inner sanctum.
Re:Android Honeycomb not immediately open sourced
by davidw on Friday March 25, 2011 @04:22PM
(#2370190)
> Isn't Darwin open source in the same way Android is?
Not really. Android is a complete system, with a kernel, libraries and the whole GUI on top of that. Darwin is just the kernel, and I think they've sort of phased out doing much with the 'open source' aspect of it.
However, it's "the best we've got", and all things considered, it's pretty good: Google could have kept many things much more tightly controlled and still been somewhat 'open' (see Windows vs Mac).
Steve Jobs harping about it though is sort of nonsensical: great, pick your nit, but to really make me stand up and care, go them one better, which is something he will never, ever do.